Ponies you're surprised that non-collectors don't like?

[Leave a Whisper]

"Tic Tac Toe looks creepy with her devil red eyes" is what I have heard from my sister LOL

My daughter thinks poor Galaxy is creepy for that same reason. lol

[scarletjul]

My mom only likes the most basic of ponies - no TAF, no so softs, no Twinkle Eyes.
I can't imagine anyone who wouldn't like at least Nightglider, but my mom does not.

She especially doesn't like Sweetheart Sisters mold, but she does think that the G3s are cute enough. 

[Strandperle]

My SO thinks that the sitting ponies look weird. And I love them to bits because they're so special!

[aquamarinemolly]

I've made a sort-of opposite observation- it seems that all the non-collectors who check out my pony shelf gravitate towards Nachtlicht, they seem to really like her unexpected dark blue color.

[Khayman81]

My bf hates all of them, he doesn't get why I like them so much. And he thinks twinkle eyes are just freaky...
On the other hand my mother loves all of them, the colored hair, etc. She likes Bridal Beauty a lot... maybe I should give her mine as Xmas gift.

[Leave a Whisper]

My daughter loves MLP, but thinks Fizzy is only okay. Bah!

[ponycake]

My twin nieces (preteens at the time) thought the seaponies were HILARIOUS and wouldn't stop laughing about them. lmao. I love the seaponies :'( I like pretty much every group of ponies.

I know sweetheart sisters are less popular but I really like them, but my mom thinks they're weird dinosaurs.

[Kittywhiskers]

but my mom thinks they're weird dinosaurs.

She should see Cutesaurus then.

[Leave a Whisper]

My twin nieces (preteens at the time) thought the seaponies were HILARIOUS and wouldn't stop laughing about them. lmao. I love the seaponies :'( I like pretty much every group of ponies.

I know sweetheart sisters are less popular but I really like them, but my mom thinks they're weird dinosaurs.

Weird dinosaurs?!