In your expert opinion - who's the most common G1 pony?

[jrr74]

I am going to go with Windy from my very limited experience.  I swear there is one of her in almost every lot I have bought.  Then Peachy 

[bluerose9978]

For me it's NBBE Baby Cuddles. For some reason I always have like 20 of her and it's definitely followed by Sundance. I have an abundance of her as well.

[ringwraith10]

For me it's NBBE Baby Cuddles. For some reason I always have like 20 of her and it's definitely followed by Sundance. I have an abundance of her as well.

Oh, yes, NBBE Baby Cuddles is definitely the most common baby. I have a bunch of her, too!

[HelloGoodbye]

Although I'm sure she isn't actually the most common, I always seem to end up with Glory!  I have an accidental mini army of her now, and I think I'm going to keep increasing its size because I love her!

[scarletjul]

Why is Peachy so common, anyhow?  It seems odd that a playset pony would be so common, as compared to other, cheaper, ponies.  Did every little girl own the Pretty Parlor?

Speaking of, I also find Majesty a lot - when I find g1s - and never in good condition. 

[BethMcBeth]

Cotton Candy, Peachy, Firefly then Applejack at least for me. LOL!!! Otherwise I would say High Flyer I got like 6 at one point!! !!!!

[LadyMoondancer]

Playsets were the go-to Christmas gift, something a little fancier than a single pony.  I used to have tons of Majestys.  I think she is common because her playset was the most dramatic and asked for, while Peachy is common because her playset was the most affordable.  (That and the Baby Buggy.)  Lemon Drop is also super common, though.  It's too bad there aren't as many surviving playsets as there are playset ponies!

[Arokiss]

My guess is Sundance.

*JM*

[Bibinettepony]

I would say Peachy then Cotton candy. 

[The_Loner]

For me it's definately Italy Peachy! I have like 20 of her! She seems to be in almost every lot of ponies. Even if all the other ponies in the lot are either knock-offs or more recent ponies Italy Peachy is very often hiding in there too!

[Kittycat]

I´d say that Hong Kong and China variants of Lemon Drop are very common finds here. I also find Italy Peachy or Pony Bride quite often.

[BrightLight]

It is definitely Peachy! And the second most common around here is Pina Colada.

[HappyHounds]

I must say, I feel Firefly is the most common G1.

I see her everywhere on Ebay! She seems to be in a good amount of the lots, etc.
I see Cotton Candy a bunch too.

[PinkRosedust]

For me it's Sundance. I probably have at least 15 of her, mostly by accident. I think I've left her behind in the wild twice now, also. I haven't found/acquired nearly as many Peachys!

[lemonice]

Peachy and lemon drop