In your expert opinion - who's the most common G1 pony?

[Strawberry Swirl]

Wow, I'd like to live in a place where Snuzzle and Minty were common.

My pick is Cotton Candy though.

[invaderhorizongreen]

For me it is cotton candy as I still have two extra and melody I wound up with four of them.

[Broken Irishwoman]

Definitely Italian Peachy.

[cyberunicorn]

Cherries jubalee for me I know others find her a it allusive but when I first started collecting I bought large lots and she always turned up for me and I was never able to sell most of them on. Turned in to one of my armies in the end

[Taffeta]

How can Firefly even be in this poll when she wasn't sold in every country? In the UK Firefly is uber-rare to non-existent in the wild, which ought to discount her (and every other pony which was not sold in all locations) from a most common pony contest. You can't be the most common pony if you weren't available to half the fanbase!

I voted Peachy. Sold everywhere, multiple versions and so common even her Nirvana versions don't sell for much

But if Firefly counts, so does Kiss Curl...

[mlp4me]

Peachy here. Lemon Drop a close second...

[StrawberryScoops]

For me it is Sundance. She is everywhere here! I must have had about 10 or more come through my hands (usually sold with a pony I wanted) and multiple that I just left behind which I saw second hand.

I've often seen others mention Peachy and Cotton Candy being overly common, but I haven't come across very many.

[shadowlark]

I say Glory cause every lot I look at on ebay seems to have at least one Glory included, usually 2 or 3!

[ponytales]

I spent a good few minutes deciding over Peachy or Cotton Candy. I went with Cotton Candy.

[DalaPony]

Peachy here. I've managed to amass 15, with a 16th on the way shortly. Every time I look on eBay there are multiples of her - she's unavoidable 

[SunbeamV]

Personally, I can't seem to escape Blossom!

[scarletjul]

Moondancer seems to be the most common over here.

[Sapling]

I've been collecting a month now and have three tootsies and two poseys and two gustys already. I think glory and moondancer are rarer in the UK.

[lovesbabysquirmy]

1. CC
2.  Peachy
3. Firefly

[daffodil101]

Cotton Candy, then probably Peachy.  Though Blossom is a close third!  I don't see that many Fireflys, gotta say, but I've had a ton of Windy and Parasol.

I used to think AJ and Bow Ties were really common, but now that I like them more than I did as a kid I'm always looking out for them in good condition

And I reckon the darker-blue Bow Tie is more common than light blue.