if you could only keep one pony...

[LittleHoneyPie]

What a difficult decision it would be between Lickety Split and Little Honey Pie, both childhood ponies. I was always so proud of my Little Honey Pie, that I played with so carefully in order to keep her hair pristine all these years. However, I think Lickety Split would probably win out, the pony who started it all.

[EeveeMUA]

My childhood G2 Princess Silver Swirl,  she means a lot to me and holds so many great memories!

[ponyluv85m]

Would be my Magic Star from childhood! She just looks so regal in her stance!

[FarDreamer]

Parasol - first pony I ever got as a kid

It's a close call with Baby Noddins though, Baby Rabbit in my Pony Land.  She was one of my favorites as a kid, liked doing all the things I liked to do - play soccer, garden, she likes rabbits and elephants, her favorite color is purple.

[StrawberryMeadow]

My childhood Twinkler. The only G1 from my personal collection I have left. She's moved house with me like, 10 times. No clue how she's stills o minty. She even spent many years on a window ledge!

[Beldarna]

ft baby Nortstar. She was one of the first, if not the first, pony I ever got and we've had so many great adventures together. I was three years old when she flew into my life so she's been with me for a very long time.

[Doedeardarling]

Hmm. Well, if I could just keep one, and I couldn't start my collection ever again, then it would be Fizzy. She's my favorite, and usually the one that sits on my table instead of in the shelf with others.

[EeveeMUA]

Hmm. Well, if I could just keep one, and I couldn't start my collection ever again, then it would be Fizzy. She's my favorite, and usually the one that sits on my table instead of in the shelf with others.

Fizzy is my favourite pony too I also keep one of mine separate, she has her own special balloon! 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Sky_Rocket_Sammie]

One of the two G1 Sky Rockets. I got them as part of the Arena summer swap last year.

[tikibirds]

Oh gosh. Do I pick a rare nirvana or one that I had as a kid?
Childhood Chacha the llama
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


If I were to go the Nirvana route:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Elwyn]

Childhood Dancing Butterflies would be the one, but if I could leave my DB behind.. maybe Dutch Butterfly or maybe Baby Lollipop (seems like I have a thing with yellow ponies). I guess my choice would be Baby Lollipop anyway, she is too cute!

[Bibinettepony]

  so hard I really need 2 ponies  well I would say my HK Tickle!!!

[Harmonie]

I'm very new to collecting, and currently only have G3 toys (I have some G4 merchandise, but none of them are the official brushables).

I think I'll have to go with Jazz Matazz. I ordered her mainly because "OMG trumpet pony!"... I played the trumpet back during G3, and I thought it was really neat to see a pony with a wind instrument cutie mark. However, once she came in I fell in love with her altogether. Such beautiful colors!

[TickledPink]

Dang this is a hard question.  I absolutely adore my childhood bowtie and would be devestated if anything happened to her..but I also have some really cool nirvana ponies I'd be hardpressed to part with!!

[kCherry]

I would keep Applejack, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zacf7WemRpw

  That's not cheating, right? :p