if you could only keep one pony...

[Karma]

I would be torn between my Goldilocks or Comic Com Pony/muffin pony. I love them both, but Pony represents a turning point in my life. I won her when I was fighting to find the right doctors for my diseases. So, even though she was one that I got for nothing, she's priceless to me <3

[sparkykandy]

Has a very small collection that only consists of G4s, so this is an easy question for me.  I would go with Diamond Rose.  It took me a while to warm up to her, but I love her colors and her cutie mark. 

[lindsayrose1985]

It's so hard right! So many to choose from lol its lovely hearing everyone stories

[Nekoi]

Would be my Magic Star from childhood! She just looks so regal in her stance!

Me too! She was my very first pony

[Thrice]

Oh jeez. I'm very in love with my Sunlight.

[Rainbowrific Renia]

I'd have to go with my very first (and so far only) G1 pony, Night Glider.  I'm absolutely in love with her!

I love my G4s, but there's just something about Night Glider... 

[Ponytails]

So very hard!  My childhood fav Magic Star (so many adventures, haircuts, and tub times!)......or my childhood Mimic (minty bc I disliked her as a kid so I rarely played w her)...or my childhood fav twin babies Noodles and Doodles (vivid memories of getting them MIB and keeping them with me 24-7 for a good month after)?  Or my fav pony ever G3 Shenanigans........

I THINK Shenay would win. But its a really hard choice. How about 1 from each gen? ;-)

[Ledbyrd]

Wow...this is really hard. I would probably go with my favorite childhood pony Princess Sparkle for sentimental reasons. But I might be tempted to choose my Dutch Heart pony instead because I just love her so much and didn't think I would ever get her.

[Shiverdam]

Probably my childhood SS Ribbon. I would sleep with her sometimes as a kid. As I grew she'd just hang out on my nightstand to keep the bad dreams away.

[freyjaloh]

lindsayrose1985, i currently dun have any so soft. Hehe...my only so soft is deflocked northstar.  If really i can only have 1 pony, then its would be my G3 Rainbowberry. 

[apanda0622]

Easy choice for me!  I would keep Dancing Butterflies!  Although I would miss Sugarberry!

[teacher316]

So hard to choose! It's neat to hear everyone's different stories about their favorites!
I would pick TAF yum yum as she's been my favorite for years, she's so pretty!

[bluerose9978]

Glow in the dark Princess Royal Blue. She was my grail for so long and one of the few ponies my husband has ever bought me.

[SunPony]

Ah, I think it would have to be Tic-Tac-Toe.  I have such fond memories of playing with her as a kid.  She was one I would always take out on adventures (travelling).  And she's just awesome 

[slj84]

Easy choice. My childhood cheif..