I found it!

[MorningGlorysParadise82]

I finally figured out who my missing Fairy Tail was! I had been IDing my accessories and I have the accessories for 3 Fairy Tails. I knew I had Tutu Tails cause she survived. I supected I had tasty tails but there was one that I couldn't pin down. The accessories pointed to Twilight Tails or another one and while I could easily see me picking Twilight Tails I didnt have proof. Well I was going through my tub I keep my backcards in and I have stuff for LLL and Disney stuff too and to my amazement I found Twilight Tails backcard! PROOF! I really did have her! Now I know who to look for! So stoked!

[nudging this over to Off Topic for you - kiwimlp ]

[Khema]

Congrats on solving the mystery and good luck on your search!

[MorningGlorysParadise82]

Thanks! i don't plan on collecting all the Fairy Tails but I would like to have the ones I had back.

[achab1984]

Congrats

[kiwimlp]

I really like the FT birds.  Good luck with your collection

[kaoskat]

Congrats! That's awesome!

[MorningGlorysParadise82]

Thanks! I wasn't sure if I posted in the right place either so thanks for the move!