That one pony you always keep, even though you already have several?

[MikeysGrrrl]

For me it's G4 Rarity (went from having 4 to 23 in less than 3 months, that's her in all her sizes and variations) and G1 Baby Glory (I think I'm at about 7 of her now, both US and Germany versions plus rehairs).

[G4Sweeties]

Just like every G4 collector, I have an army of Pinkie Pies that are too cute for me to get rid of

[Moony]

Alphabittle xD I always pick her up when I see her lol!

[Lollipop]

All wingers my little army is growing nicely hehe

Lollipop sent from her Nokia Lumia 1020 using Tapatalk

[brightberry]

I seem to have a bunch of Butterscotch.  None of them are perfect but each looks a little different from the other.  I never seem to be able to let one go.

[Sunshine]

I have a problem keeping Lemon Drops... even if I have 10 that look almost the same, or are in poor condition... I just can't let her go...

[himmie]

My unintentional army is Oakly. I have five + one MIB. Two are from childhood and the others are all from lots. He's too cute to part with once he's here.

[Sarah-Bee]

I'm ruthless - duplicates are sold. End of.

[Gingerbread]

Twinkle Eyes! Can never, ever turn down a TE in any condition.

But my unintentional army seems to vary - it was Baby Bow Tie; had about ten who I sold eventually here years ago. Now it is Cotton Candy and Bow Tie, these were my first two ponies as a child so kind of understand that, managed to trade my last two a few days ago. And for some reason I have several sets of the G1 first six in various places...a group in one of my show stables, a group in a random carry bag, a group on the shelf....once they are in groups that's it lol they stay

[applejackbunny]

Yes, Applejack! 

[Corona]

Wingers. I have two bait wingers I can do nothing with but I can't let them go. Also Dancing Butterflies, after I saved one with the grossest innards ever I can't turn away a DB in need.

[partypony566]

I have never had that problem.....I only deliberately collect G1 Minty but I used to get a lot of Sundances and Cotton candys in lots

[wyndeboo]

mine would be applejack and seaflower

[LordBlumiere]

At the moment it seems to be G4 Rarity, though thankfully with variations I only have 2 that are extremely similar I would have 3, but one's slated to be customized into a friend's OC pony. But if I did get another Rarity... I'd probably keep her, haha! Can't turn down that little darling for long!

[mlp4me]

Nightglider. I had two then I stumbled upon the third with a haircut... I usually part with duplicates. I just can't seem to bear to part with her (or do anything with the one with the haircut). I do like walking pose ponies best...