It's all in the eyes

[Jinxxy]

The eyes are one of the best parts about the G1s. so unique and gorgeous! The perfect mix of cute and sweet and rarely replicated even in customs <3<3<3

[achab1984]

Looks like the G1 one ponies are winning But they are all winners in my eyes

[tealslippers]

Starly, you're being weird.  Why do you care what eyes people like?

I love the colour variety in G1, the expressiveness of G4 and the shape / layout of the G3!

[sundaygirl]

I voted for G1, but both G3 and G4 are cute in their own way.

[Summerlycoris]

I picked the G3 eyes. They're just so beautiful with the two tones and symbols in them. All the other eyes are great too, though.

[hathorcat]

*sigh*...a warning in this thread, really?

How about instead of that...we just, well I dont know? get back on the topic? And that means everyone. If you dont have anything to say about pony eyes...move on to the next thread please.

[Ice Crystal]

G4 eyes for me. Goopy and disgustingly cute.

But I love pretty much all the eyes! G2 would have been my second pick. I love the eyes on them even if I don't collect them.

[keylimepony]

G1 I especially like Twinkle Eyed ponies

[NoDivision]

While I love G1 eyes, I think G3 did the most with them. All the multicolor eyes, and the ones with the different shaped little "shimmers" like waterfires flame and applejack's apple... just so cute!

[Prince Primbrose]

While I love G1 eyes, I think G3 did the most with them. All the multicolor eyes, and the ones with the different shaped little "shimmers" like waterfires flame and applejack's apple... just so cute!

Funnily enough, I used to really dislike G3 eyes because of the little heart/star/apple/etc. shaped symbols! I guess I thought they were tacky or something; now I just love them! They're a cute little way to give the eyes more pop and personality.

[pop-girl]

I adore G1 eyes - as others have said they're very sweet in appearance.

[Rosencrantz]

I went with g1, they seem to be perfectly proportioned to me.

[wizzer218]

G1 all the way for me....but also love love love twinkle Eyed ponies...I know they are both in the same category..... but the TEs are so awesome!

[VanillaBean]

G3 for me, I love how they incorporate two colours together, & the little icons are cute, although sometimes they can be a little distracting.
G1 is a close second, they look so innocent & gentle.
I think the gems in G2 are a nice touch, but they don't translate very well into the artwork. Sometimes the eye sparkles can look a little creepy xD

[Keelee_von_Cupcake]

I picked G3 eyes, because they maintain the sweet, classic, cartoon shape of the G1 eyes, while adding multiple colors and symbols that just make them really exciting and lovely. I can't resist that extra detail and exuberance.

I definitely like how much shape variety there is in G4 eyes, though. And Nightmare Moon has the best eyes of any pony, in my opinion. The gradient just makes them look so much more alive than any of my other ponies!