So whose your bad penny?

[hathorcat]

Baby Stella! I found 3 of her in 3 months once.

For your bad penny swap perhaps we can come up with so something...you ll need to give us some time to think how it could work. I think a travelling box amoung difrerent groups would work better and there would need to be quite a few conditions such as perhaps having at leaat 2 pennies from different generations.

[Ginger]

Buzzer, High Flyer, and Baby Stocking keep coming my way.

Right now I have 4 each of Buzzer and High Flyer, and I finally got little Stocking sorted out... for now.

[scarlettkitty81]

I have not been thrifting in awhile but thought I would stop by my favorite thrift store tomorrow since it is by my dentist.

When I did go I was always coming across G3 Sunny Daze in various poses and Valenshy!

I rarely come across G1's and when I do they are always super baity

[Spectrum]

I've some how managed to acquire 9 Gingerbreads..

[Binny]

I've some how managed to acquire 9 Gingerbreads..

Lucky!

My collection isn't very big yet, the mane 6 are my only bad pennies so far really. I think I have one g3 double and surprisingly no g3 Pinkie Pies (but like three or four g4 ones )

[MLPWhitney]

OMG SS Best Wishes!! EVERYWHERE!!

[Cherry_Sunset]

McDonald's Celestia. I've found about 5 of her in Goodwills and second hand stores. It's probably a good thing because I accidentally ruined one trying to customize it!

[Diamond]

Baby Stella! I found 3 of her in 3 months once.

For your bad penny swap perhaps we can come up with so something...you ll need to give us some time to think how it could work. I think a travelling box amoung difrerent groups would work better and there would need to be quite a few conditions such as perhaps having at leaat 2 pennies from different generations.

See all we need is someone with some good swap organizing skills!  I nominate Cat!  *runs and hides in the cellar*

[SeashellnBubbles]

Perhaps someone should get it started and the first 4 or 5 people get it back again at the end of the swap so they have a good chance to take what they want...or the box just makes the rounds forever...like the ponies it contains!!

[Sunshine]

G3.5 Cheerilee is my bad penny, and because of that, I have like an unintentional army. I HATE IT... lol

[Mermaid]

Yes cat runs great swaps!! Sign me up!

[StrawberryScoops]

Definitely Sundance and Sparkler (early unicorn not MGR) for me. Sundance has been following me my whole life. I had 3 of by the time I was 6 and since I started officially collecting that number has grown.

[bbassel]

I was thinking as people add ponies they can write on a sheet what pony they took and what they put in. That wsy everything will be kept track of : ) just an idea.

[TexasGal]

I was thinking as people add ponies they can write on a sheet what pony they took and what they put in. That wsy everything will be kept track of : ) just an idea.

I like that idea!  Shame we couldn't drop in a few small extras...stickers, a piece of jewelry from me or two, nail polish, etc.  something small so not much extra weight, but fun and everyone could take one?   Moar ideas?

[applejackbunny]

I'd have to say Cherries Jubilee (only buy G1s).  Ugggggh.  I don't really like her that much.  She is very hard to sell, even mint.  I'd much rather see Tootsie--I'm in the minority who prefer her!

I'm so glad to hear someone else say that, lol! I can't stand her! I had her once, briefly, when I first started collecting, but I just couldn't live with her so I got rid....sorry Cherries! But yes, she's always on Ebay...her and Peachy!

I can't even collect anything in what I call the Cherries Jubilee pose now, so even Tootsie is out of the question, lol!

Post Merge: March 08, 2013, 03:43:23 PM

Pinkie pie, the pony that is everywhere in the universe!

Couldn't agree more....tired of her now! Especially as she's not the most inspired of ponies!!