Only One.

[nhal039]

gusty

[zzzova]

It would be my lose Cutesaurus, the first pony my fiance bought me 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[zabe77]

The other pony in your photo is my choice! Cotton Candy, my first childhood pony

That Barnacle army is impressive!

[Shy Violet]

I love so many of my ponies, I'd be so sad to not have them but if I could only keep one pony it would be my NSS Gusty ♥ she's my first childhood pony and will always have a special place in my heart

[Cool.Breeze]

I've been sitting here thinking for an awfully long time.... but I think I'll have to say baby Firefly. ( If I had a Cool Breeze, then it would be her someday... )

[Rainbowjuice]

It's have to be my carousel pony.
I made her myself but she's too special to let go.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Esbayne]

And Mohawk
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

:O I love him so much!! How'd you (Or the customizer) make the little leather jacket? I'd love to make some for Headbanger and Shining Armor.


But for me, god I dunno who I'd pick... Probably a toss up between Headbanger, Shining Armor and Johnny.

Headbanger is my heavy metal Pheonix pony, I made him to mix my love of metal and ponies. xD Shining Armor (the FS one) is his best friend and is a punk rocker because of his mohawk. They both have little guitars.
Johnny is another custom, he is my absolute favorite character of mine and has a ton of meaning to me, he's had a pony version of himself ever since I can remember and the custom pony I did of him means a lot to me because of that.

Either that or maybe Kingsly, because she's always been one of my favorites.

[Stormness_1]

Hard question! There's Ruby Lips, who was my first pony, but then I have so many others that are super sentimental, like my FS G4's my hubby bought me, or the ponies I traded from my best friend, there's so many of those! Sweet Pocket, who my uncle saved from the rubbish dump, or G3 Royal Bouquet, who I bought on a whim, and left MIB for almost a year before opening her and getting me back into collecting again! Not to mention some of my favourite ponies - Nightglider, shaggy, bowtie.... aargh!

Waay too hard!!!

[Marlin]

oooh... umm...

Sugarapple? Childhood Bowtie or Nightglider? Rosette? Flowerbelle? ARGH!!!

Breaks rules and grabs a handful!! 

[Pythia]

Probably my childhood Twist.

[sadako]

I would pick my G3 styling Rainbow Dash as she is the first pony I bought as an adult. I was having a bad day and left work early and went to Zellers, I was looking at the toys and there she was. I fell in love with her at once. She means the most to me of all my ponies.

[DancingPhoenix]

Oh wow, the first pony that popped into my head was Crumpet. She was a grail for so long and I adore mine so very much. But then I remember my Surprise army and Mimic (who is always with Crumpet), and of course Speedy who has one of my favorite pony color combos.
Arrgh my brain! (but my final answer is Crumpet)

[CottonTALE]

If I was only allowed to keep one pony, it would be my SDCC Drama Pony... I paid alot to get her home to me

[ViciousJupiter]

I'd have t stick with Galaxy.  I absolutely Adore her

[disturbed-rainbow]

You Guys are great!  I know it would be hard to choose just one!! But lucky enough I don't believe we'll ever have to choose just one