Only One.

[disturbed-rainbow]

If you had to choose ONLY ONE pony to keep out of your whole collection, which would it be?

I've looked over my beauties and I wouldn't know how to do it, I love them all so very much.  If I had to only choose one, I've decided it should be Minty...

She's my upmost favorite of my entire collection <3

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[josiekat]

If it was any pony, then it would be my purple Totsy. She is the only pony in my collection that was a childhood pony.

If it this is for actual MLPs only, then that's tough. My gut tells me that I would keep one of my Bluebelles. Bluebelle is my favorite pony. But.....I have a fondness for one of my Medley's, and I would hate to get rid of her. But.....then I think about ponies like my Mimic and my Diamond Dreams that were gifts from my husband, so they have sentimental value. The same go for ponies that were friend's childhood ponies like my Satin and Lace. Or almost all of my G4's which were birthday and christmas presents from family.

Basically, I don't know if I could keep just one MLP......so, I go back to my Purple Totsy. lol

[disturbed-rainbow]

Put it that way it does make it hard to choose, I too have gifts and ones I worked so hard to get... Ahh! But I've had minty for quite a long time now..

[Sarah-Bee]

That would be impossible But supposing it had to happen it would be a choice between the ones Joe my hubby bought as gifts for me. i'd have to sit and decide with them all in front of me I think... it would probably be Rapunzel though as he gave her to me for our first anniversary.

[Spike]

Would be Salty. Favorite pony <3

[KaibaGirl007]

It would be very hard to choose just one, but without a doubt it would be one of my childhood ponies.... and I'd have to pick them whilst blindfolded

[garnetfirebird]

Definitely sparkly Sunspot. She's the pony I remember most clearly from my childhood. I took her everywhere.

[nirvana]

Hmm, it's hard. Cotton Candy was the first pony I can remember, but I always had a kink for pegasi. Skydancer and Firefly are my all-time favourites, but if I have to choose only one then it would be Firefly.

[zora]

that would be chief! he is the last childhood pony i have

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[kittybethy]

Truly, of course!

[NoDivision]

It would be Barnacle, obviously... but which one!?!?
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


 I'd have a very hard time choosing between:

The Captain (my first Barnacle)
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


And Mohawk
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[svleonard]

Raincurl

[Griffin]

I would never be able to get rid of my childhood ponies! Or actually, half of them are my sister's... which would make it even more difficult. But if I was allowed to give all our childhood ponies to my sister, for example (i.e. not keep them ) and then choose only one of my "actual"  collection to keep, it would definitely be UK Gusty. Gusty is my favourite pony and I think it's the UK/NSS version I like best. Or maybe it's just because she was my first Gusty.

[Saber-Toothed Crow]

My Barnacle. It would be difficult to leave the others, but he has the most meaning to me.

[Sprinkles]

Only one??? I can't do that! I can, however, narrow it down to two ponies: G3 Star Swirl because she was my absolute favorite when I was little and G4 Fluttershy that is has become my new favorite