When your out hunting for ponies in the wild....

[LadyLuckyLeaf]

I'd love to find Rose Petal Place or Sylvanian Families.

[Doedeardarling]

I look for Pokemon plushies for my sister's collection.

[BlushingBlue]

I keep an eye out for Fairy Tails, She-Ra, Jem, and LLL stuff. Doesn't mean I see any, but hey.

[Skelletonimp]

Bratz horses and lion king things ^^

[RainbowRay]

I look for Pokemon, and also dragons and other plush animals that I like the look of!
I also keep an eye out for useful looking fabrics to recycle into plushies.

[Harmonie]

I guess you could say that if I saw a rare early Beanie Baby (back when they started) - which probably won't ever happen - I might be interested in getting it since I never actually managed to get one back when I was into them in the late 90s. (Of course not, I was like 9 or 10 and couldn't ask my parents to spend that much!  )

I'm really not looking for toys beyond ponies. My true interest is wind instruments! I've gotten a trombone and French horn so far... In almost just the span of the last month. 

[Aurora]

Wow! I don't think I've ever seen a woodwind at a yard sale- nice job!
I like drinking glasses with old advertising, dish towels, and pretty much any 80's girl toy- I keep promising myself I'll sell them, but it hasn't really happened for a while.

[Skeen]

I look for 80's toys in general, and also for Sierra/Cocktel Vision/Apogee pc games from the 80's and 90's for my husband. 

[gabumon]

I've seen almost all of the things that have been mentioned here!

Maybe we should set up a "cost + shipping" thrift toy hunting network!

[cyberunicorn]

The vintage puppy in my pockets,  I have quite a few of them but I never do have any luck. That and more recently older silvanian families once again not much luck but the fun is in the fact you might just find that one treasure. Hidden away one day.

[katrine2309]

I'd love to find Rose Petal Place or Sylvanian Families.

I would love to find some vintage sylvanians! Never seen any "in the wild though".... :/

[Harmonie]

Wow! I don't think I've ever seen a woodwind at a yard sale- nice job!

Oh, I didn't find them at yard sales - I found them at vintage/antique shops. My mom and I have been to like 30 in the last few months. 

Haven't seen a single MLP of any generation. 

[Shimmer Mist]

I try to keep an eye out for Transformers but I find fewer of those than I do ponies. ;~; I also keep an eye out for plushies that might catch my eye or ceramic unicorns.

[SkyCakes]

I keep an eye out for any strawberry shortcake stuff or hello kitty things.

[Wardah]

I've seen almost all of the things that have been mentioned here!

Maybe we should set up a "cost + shipping" thrift toy hunting network!

Yeah.