PC on G1 Collection

[Robyntbs]

Hello everyone,
I am a long time lurker here, but haven’t contributed much. Hopefully some of you can give me some advice on the value of a pony collection. Someone locally is selling the ponies listed below. They are  all in very good to mint condition. I have not seen the accessories, but she said she has almost all of them as well. What do you guys think would be a good/fair price to pay for everything?

Satin 'n' Lace
Tux 'n' Tails
Wildflower (sweetheart sister pony)
Baby Starflower (baby sparkle pony)
Baby Sugarberry
Baby Pearly (fancy mermaid pony)
Creamsicle the giraffe
Baby Moondancer (pearly)
Baby Firefly (pearly)
Sunny Bunch (merry go round pony)
Baby Dancing Butterflies
Dancing Butterflies
Sky Dancer (summer wing pony)
Secret Beauty (secret surprise pony)
Twinkler (sparkle pony)
Baby Princess Sparkle
Firefly (movie version)
Skippity Doo (so soft pony)
Sky Rocket (twinkle eye pony)
Hearthrob
Baby Heartthrob (beddy bye pony)
Sniffles and Snookums (baby twin ponies)
Cuddles (magic message pony)
Brilliant Bloom (brush and grow pony)
Banana Surprise (sundae best pony)
Star Dancer (sparkle pony)
Yo yo (newborn pony)
Moon Jumper (windy wing pony)
Twice as Fancy Megan and Sundance
Merry treat (Christmas pony)
Goldilocks
Bright Glow (glow and show)
Baby Stockings
Chocolate Delight (sipping soda pony)
Birthday Pony (10th anniversary pony)


Dream beauties:
Glider
Morning glory

[lunar_scythe]

Do you know which version of satin n lace(lavender, so soft, or magenta)?  The price varies so much for the different versions of her!

[hathorcat]

Pricing here assumes nice condition and no issues So you may have to have some give and take.

Satin 'n' Lace - as mentioned, which version is going to change this price quite a bit
Tux 'n' Tails - $60-65
Wildflower (sweetheart sister pony) - $8-10 (assuming unbroken earring)
Baby Starflower (baby sparkle pony) - $8
Baby Sugarberry - $75
Baby Pearly (fancy mermaid pony) - $18-22
Creamsicle the giraffe - $10
Baby Moondancer (pearly) - $25-26
Baby Firefly (pearly) - $16-18
Sunny Bunch (merry go round pony) - $7-8
Baby Dancing Butterflies - $100
Dancing Butterflies - $7
Sky Dancer (summer wing pony) - $16-18
Secret Beauty (secret surprise pony) - $16 (assuming working saddle)
Twinkler (sparkle pony) - $12
Baby Princess Sparkle - $40
Firefly (movie version) - $15-16
Skippity Doo (so soft pony) - $10
Sky Rocket (twinkle eye pony) - $10
Hearthrob - $8
Baby Heartthrob (beddy bye pony) - $1.50
Sniffles and Snookums (baby twin ponies) - $12-14
Cuddles (magic message pony) - $6
Brilliant Bloom (brush and grow pony) - $8
Banana Surprise (sundae best pony) - $4
Star Dancer (sparkle pony) - $10
Yo yo (newborn pony) - $6
Moon Jumper (windy wing pony) - $30-35
Twice as Fancy Megan and Sundance - $25
Merry treat (Christmas pony) - $8-12
Goldilocks - $10-12
Bright Glow (glow and show) - $15-16
Baby Stockings - $6
Chocolate Delight (sipping soda pony) - $14-16
Birthday Pony (10th anniversary pony) - $14

Dream beauties:
Glider - $55-60
Morning glory - $40-45

[Baby Sugarberry]

Accessories are going to be all over the place in value depending on what "almost all of them" means.  i.e. Baby Princess Sparkle's buggy complete with all its accessories is worth easily be x2-x3 more than the pony.  Unless you get actual visual confirmation of what's included though, I wouldn't factor said accessories into the price.  Too much of a gamble.

[Robyntbs]

Thanks for the advice everyone, I appreciate it!!