Favorite Ponies in Your Herd

[tuneful87]

I have too many all time favorites but most would be those I had as a child...

Tunefull
Seaflower
Bowtie
Medley
Locket

There are too many others to mention! I would say that of my 500 or so ponies, about 100 are customs and I don't have any close feelings for any of them. Of the 400 or so left, I'd say about 1/2 I like but could live without if necessary. The other half? I'd rather die than part with them.

[MorningGlorysParadise82]

I have always loved bright ponies, so Tic-Tac-Toe, Masquerade, Tootie Tails, Skippity Doo and Quacker's were favorites, even if some I didn't get till I was an adult.
I think that's why Fluttershy appealed to me when the series came out. That and she reminded me of Posey! LOL

[cutest-curtsey]

I tend to not buy a pony if I won't love them to death, haha.  But obviously i have a few favorites.

Cute Curtsey, clearly, is my one true love of ponies. She's kinda bland, I guess but so am I so we get on well.
Silver Song is my first ever 'I must have this pony' pony, I really love her because her cutie mark is musical theather, and I've been into drama and musicals since I was very young.
G1 Applejack just because shes my only G1 (and hasn't arrived yet whoops)
Actually I just love all AppleJacks I have a mini army of her.
and lastly Skywishes and Starcatcher because I cant have one without the other.

[cricket]

My two childhood favorites were Applejack and Magic Star and they still hold a special place in my heart today.  As an adult I have come to love many others.  Angel, Locket, Posey, Bubbles, Seashell…I could go on and on!

[Harmonie]

I don't own many, and the ones I do own so far are all special to me.

Candy Cane is the pony that made me think "OMG I must start collecting" or at least get her.

Jazz Matazz is another favorite. In the past (particularly during G3) I played the trumpet. I was so enthused to find out that there was a pony with a trumpet cutie mark, so I had to have her, too!

Juniper Jade holds a special place in my heart as the first MLP I ever really knew about. I also really like her colors and pose. Although she probably wouldn't have been at the top of my list otherwise, I actually am very glad I had that reason to get her because she's a lot more beautiful and I probably would have overlooked her otherwise.

[Sukey]

My favorite pony as a child was Quackers, because of her rainbow hair(even though I thought her jewel eyes were weird) I think if I had Starshine as a child that she would've been my favorite.

My faves in my herd now are:

-Starshine
-Moonstone
-Windy
-Gusty
-Glory
-Sparkler
-Majesty
-Masquerade
-Gingerbread(looking for an upgrade of her)
-Mimic
-Quackers
-Sweet Stuff
-Baby Stocking
-Baby rainbow ponies

I find myself drawn to ponies with white bodies.  Unfortunately it is harder to find them in better condition- at least in my experience.

[Mirnyj]

This is an easy one to answer! Italy Flutterbye, Love Letter, Molasses, Snowflake, Barnacle, Pony Penny and Baby Tappy and G2 Ivy. My childhood ponies. 

[Stars]

Princess Crystal - her colour scheme is out of this world! I love her planet symbol too. She's also in my favourite pose. Definitely the most unique princess of G2. Can't get enough!

Beauty Parlor (SLH) Ivy - Wow! I was lucky enough to buy a beautiful one with her hair uncut and silky. She is completely stunning - that hair is divine. Another one in my favourite pose too.

[reanna-mator]

Night Glider, Wind Whistler, Princess Sparkle, and Wind Drifter, my childhood pony.

I recently brought back Hopscotch from the UK and she's up there too. <3

[TickleMePink]

Tickle
Peachy
Baby Cotton candy
Starshine
SS Lofty
Moon Jumper

And at the moment my two favorites are: Daddy Apple Delight and Macau Jenny

[Junipur]

My first pony love was Bowtie, I just think she is so cute
Then I met Flutterbye, who by the way was a boy, as I had no idea about the real pony boys 
Then when I started collecting for real I realised I am just in love with the pegasi, so in no particular order:
Ice Crystal, Yum Yum, Dancing Butterflies, Hearth Throb, Blueberry Baskets, Honeycomb and so on ..............

[Wildshadow]

My favorites are my childhood ponies

Surprise, Coco Berry, Steamer, Dainty Dahlia, Diamond Dreams, Honeysuckle, to many others to list... and all the earlier ones with my name on them that my mom put on the pony X D She put their name and then my name on it with a smile face to represent it was mine and not my sister's. My sister got the weird smile face with 'hair' sticks coming out of the head X D

I've even kept my sister's ponies which some of them were; Quarterback, Sherbet, Whizzer, Edgar, the blue teeny tiny twins, few others I've forgotten....

[Peppermint Pie]

Peppermint Crunch was always my favorite pony along with Fireball. G1:s. Peppermint Crunch because she smells so nice! And Fireball because he was the only boypony I had and I just love his colors!

[scarletjul]

Wind Whistler
Crumpet
Satin and Lace
Tux
Baby Crumpet
Baby Princess Sparkle
Thundercloud
TAF Nightglider
MO Mommy pony

[doxiechic16]

I have a number of favorites, but below are two standouts:

Baby Sugarcake – She’s yellow, super adorable, and was one of my childhood ponies.  I feel happy whenever I look at her.  If she wasn’t so expensive and HTF, I’d love to have an army of her.

Baby Lickety Split – I was OBSESSED with her when I was a kid because of MLP: The Movie, but I could NEVER find her.  (I used to try to pretend my Baby Cotton Candy was her, but it just wasn't the same.)  I was super excited to get the chance to FINALLY own the First Tooth version of Baby Lickety Split as an adult collector, and I’m particularly in love with the Play and Care version I have now.