Somewhere, over the rainbow

[Mermaid]

That was devastatingly hard! I ultimately chose starshine, but this is one of my favorite sets! Sunlight was a close second.

[Elfpony]

Seems like this was a tough choice for a lot of us.  I had to pick Skydancer in the end.  She just looks so cheerful and happy, she makes me happy every time I look at her.

Elf

[Ren-Ren]

Wow, I can't believe Windy is in last place! Just goes to show how beautiful this whole line is. I picked her, but it was a tough choice between her and Sunlight. Love Starshine's white and symbol, but I've never liked that pose.

As a kid I always called Sky Dancer "Peabody" because she was yellow (even though the spelling doesn't work out right, heh). I do like her a lot now, though.

[shimmlight]

Moonstone, she was my first G1

[Loona]

it was hard to choose between Sky Dancer and Starshine (one of my favourite poses), but Sky Dancer won in the end.
normally I don't like yellow that much, but when it comes to ponies it is one of my favourite body colours, and to me it seems to go better with the rainbow hair colours. still, Starshine is a close second.

[VanillaBean]

Sunlight! 
She's such an adorable little beauty, & my only rainbow pony so far.
I should own Starshine as well, but she got lost in the mail. :<

[aluke]

I went with Sky Dancer. Something about that yellow with a rainbow mane just makes her pop. Plus, you can never go wrong with bird related symbols.

[Beldarna]

Sky Dancer. It's the name. Dancing in the sky, how cool is that? I also have a weakness for her pose.

[lovesbabysquirmy]

Starshine is a childhood pony!

[mlp4me]

Oh Starshine, how I adore thee...

[Ringlets]

This was definitely another tough choice
In the end I chose Starshine - I love the pose and the colours- but mostly because she was the first of this set that I ever saw in person when i was a kid. she was my best friends pony and we used to play for hours with our herd (we joined herds and both bought ponies together when we had enough money and were a bit older)  - Starshine and sprinkles (who belonged to me) were best buddies and they were a bit like Rainbow dash is in FIM ..but ....my friend had Starshine stolen and it upset us both so much.. I've often wondered about buying her a replacement over the years ..but we lost contact   I know its a sad story but there are lots of happy memories attached to Starshine and to my friend too so I still like her the best of the rainbow ponies

[Bibinettepony]

  such a story Ringlets ! Thanks for sharing. But you are right you have to remember only very good moments 

[Pegaso80]

I really love this set, the only one I have completed so far, even I have some doubles. I chose Moonstone because of the blue body and the planets and the pose and she's a unicorn... but Windy is very beautiful as well, I love her symbol. 

[gemini_pony]

Moonstone for me, even though Parasol is a close second.

[snwbear24]

Starshine and Sky Dancer for me I love them both!