If you could only keep one pony for the rest of your life, who would it be?

[shimmlight]

I know it's a hard choice but if you were only allowed to have one pony forever, who would you choose? For me, Chief. I've never loved a pony like I love Chief xD

[Roogna]

my childhood lavender woosie

[SourdoughStomper]

If a custom pony, I'd probably pick my rearing G1 Sunflower. I made it myself and while it's not a perfect custom by any means, it represents me and was made by me.

If a Hasbro pony - probably Sunny Daze G3. She sucked me back into pony collecting and brought me to the Arena. She's also so bright, rainbow-y and sunny. Though G1s are always my favorite, I just can't see myself being unattached to Sunny Daze.

[lunar_scythe]

Ugh, I don't think I could pick just one!  Most of my favorites would just be baits to anyone else, so I'd have to keep 2, my childhood starflower(given to me by a close friend) and the poor error with her nose bitten off! (Heh, starflower really isn't any better, she's completely brown and her chartreuse hair has faded to white...)

[hathorcat]

My Cotton Candy PJ case because she is the only childhood MLP item I have left And if it was a regular pony - then it would still be CC; trying to find out a way to replace this pony was how I came to the online pony collecting community and what started my collection!

[brightberry]

Probably my very first pony, Glory.  But I have so many wonderful memories with all of my childhood ponies, I would pine for them all.

[doxiechic16]

I would be tough, but I'd go with Baby Sugarcake.  She's my favorite.   

[Malicieuse]

Baby Glory, she was my favorite childhood pony. : )

[Icecrystalline]

PIKACHU!  Oh wait. That's not a pony!

Bubbles. My tailless, loved to death Bubbles

[Katika]

Most likely my TAF Buttons.  She's one of only a handful of ponies that spanned from childhood to adulthood and is the only one besides Chief and SS Wind Whistler (who I do not have my childhood ones of) that I distinctly remember playing with.  She's nowhere near the top of my list of actual favorite ponies, but that specific, individual TAF Buttons will stay with me even if I decide to sell the rest of my collection <3

[shadowlark]

Ooh tough choice. Probably my childhood Applejack, but I'd have to keep Baby AJ too. But she was always one of my faves when I was a kid.

But it would be hard to part with Nightglider....she was the first pony I bought when I started collecting.

[Carcina]

G3 Twirlerina.

[PrincessStarlily]

What a mean question! I have way too many favorites!

Just 'cause I'm sentimental, I'd probably pick my first pony, G3 Tink-a-tink-a-too. Or my third, fabric wings Starcatcher, which my cousin and I dubbed Pegasus Queen of Ponyland when we were little. I'm lucky enough to still own all my childhood ponies!

[Einhornbaby]

My childhood-pony G1 Sugar Apple <3

[wizzer218]

Twinkle eyed whizzer of course although.....she would be sad about not having her boyfriend....lol