Pony Nostalgia: Which pony brings back the most memories for you?

[Marigold]

I had probably about 15-25 ponies growing up, but I notice that whenever I see a certain couple of ponies, or even art of these ponies it brings me right back to childhood and my fondest memories of play.  For me it is Starshine, Windy, and Princess Sparkle that take me immediately back. 

Starshine and Windy were the first ponies I had (not counting Butterscotch whom was so well loved she was thrown out by mom when I got these two new girls).  Every time I see them I think they are the best ponies ever because they take me right back to happy memories.  Princess Sparkle was a later pony for me, but she also brings back really great memories that this time include my sister.  We both got Princess Sparkles! 

Which ponies bring you right back to your favorite memories even if they might not be your favorite ponies?

[DemureGirl]

For me it was Gypsy. She was my favourite.

Strawberry fair also takes me back. She was another I had as a child that I distinctly remember

[spottedslug]

Parasol, Dancing Butterflies, and Masquerade were the ones I played with most.

[MonstarNomNom]

Barnacle and Boysenberry Pie were my two favorites growing up and still rule over my herd together ^^ They always bring back fond childhood memories

[Hope1989]

For me they are Nightlight and Tulip <3 They were my first ponies so they're so special for me 

[Einhornbaby]

Sugar Apple, Sugar Sweet and Baby Cuddles <3 Childhood favourites!

[HelloGoodbye]

Tink-a-Tink-a-Too was my first pony when I was little.  She was always involved in my "story line" whenever I was playing ponies because she was my favorite.  Actually, she still is my favorite!  I have my original Tink-a on my bedside table, and looking at her always fills me with happy memories of the fun I had with my ponies. 

[SkyCakes]

I would say baby surprise and the other babies of that set and I played with them and their moms alot. I loved them very much with their accessories. I shall track them down someday. I am more concerned with finding other dream castle accessories. I keep telling myself maybe I will get them down the road.

[Zapper]

Ringlet and Swirly Whirly, hands down.

[hathorcat]

Oh good question. Its going to be Bow Tie, Apple Jack and Masquerade. The latter was the only pony I got to choose in store by myself - I remember standing in Woolworths, holding my mums hand and looking at the great wall of pony. I was getting a special present so that I would try and not be upset because we were moving house and I was leaving all my friends. To this day standing there with mum and picking out Masquerade is one of my strongest childhood memories. The others are because I was given their shy pose versions as presents in order to bribe me into accepting my little brother I have a picture of me standing over his bassinet in the hospital - in theory to pose with my brother but instead I am holding Applejack, her puffy sticker on my dress and a big smile on my face...it was not the new brother making me feel that way.

[Sky_Rocket_Sammie]

Firefly and Gusty. Firefly because I also had the story on tape, which was listened to a lot.
Which influenced the stories I made up for my Firefly. Gusty because unicorns are my second favorite MLP after the Pegasus. And she was one of my favorite G1 unicorns.

Which admittedly I nicknamed her Canada.

[little.fox]

Trickles and Confetti!

[Bibinettepony]

Tickle!! and when I see my Tickle I also have a smile  and have nice memories !!

[Cyber-Satan]

I have to say, I have two memories.
My very first pony was the G3 Cotton Candy I got when I was about 6..I love her.
But, the first pony that I remember bringing the most memories was when I found my first G1, Snuzzle.
...and although this might sound really weird, the thing that brings back memories the most is the smell of a G1. You know, the kind of musty plastic smell a lot of them have? That brings back the first memories I had of collecting.

[Skeen]

Buttons, Bright Night, and Princess Primrose.  They were always the heroes.