Massive MIB/MOC G3 price check, please?

[babyprincessnicole]

Hello!  I've been away from the boards for a bit, keeping busy with work and raising my toddler.  I've been working on my pony room and realized that I could use some of the room, so here I am trying to work out how to sell all these G3 ponies that are still MIB/MOC.  Before I make a sales post, I wanted to post the list here to get an idea of what to price everything at to sell.  I think I am still missing a few items from this list, which I will add as soon as I locate them.
Obviously I have a ton, so even a general idea of what to price regular release items at, or which items should be priced higher, would be great.  Also, would Craigslist or local sales be a good option, for those that I can't sell online?  Thanks for any help!

My Little Pony G3 Sales List
All are MIB/MOC unless otherwise noted
(Several have the store price sticker on the box; if this is an issue please let me know.)

Mail Order Giant Plush Frilly Frocks – opened and repackaged, never displayed
G1 rerelease: Original 6 (Both boxes First 100 release) and all 6 Rainbow Ponies

2003 Year of the Celebration:

Dazzle Surprise (mail order)
Pinkie Pie II
Rainbow Dash II
Sunny Daze II
Sweet Summertime (Euro exclusive)
Winter Snow (Euro exclusive)

2004 Friendship Ball:

Regular Release:
Alphabittle
Bee Bop
Blue Mist
Bumblesweet
Bunches o Fun x2
Cherry Blossom (value city price sticker)
Cinnamon Breeze
Crystal Lace
Cupcake
Denim Blue x2
Desert Blossom
Desert Rose
Forsythia
Gardenia Glow
Gem Blossom
Golden Delicious
Juniper Jade x2
Magic Marigold
Merriweather
Peachy Pie
Pepperberry (KB toys exclusive)
Peri Winkle
Piccolo
Rainbow Swirl
Sapphire Shores
Savannah Sage
Shenanigans (value city price sticker)
Star Shimmer  (TRU exclusive) x2
Starbeam
Sunset Sweety
Sweet Song
Triple Treat
Twilight Twinkle
Valenshy
Winterberry

Dress Up:
Crystal Lake
Royal Ribbon
Tea Leaf
Wind Wisher

Super Long Hair:
Dibble Dabble
Silly Sunshine
Silver Lining
Silver Song
Sparklesnap

Winter set:
Marshmellow Coco
Mistletoe
Snow’el

Playsets/special sets:
Avalonia Butterfly Surprise (opened, in packaging)
Lickety-Split and Portobella
Sew-and-so & Tink-a-tink-a-too with baby Keen Bean
Starcatcher with video
Sweet Reflections Dress Shop with Darling Dahlia and Goodie Goodie (Sam’s Club)
Wishing Well Princess Playset with Crystal Crown

2005 Butterfly Island:

Earth:
Beachberry
Bowtie x2
Coconut Cream
Fizzy Pop
Flippity Flop
Heather Winds
Island Rainbow
Kimono II (KB toys exclusive)
Kiwi Tart x2
Lavender Lake
Pineapple Paradise
Ribbon Wishes
Seaspray
Shell-Belle
Strawberry Reef
Twilight Twinkle
Waterfire

Pegasus:
Cloud Climber
Coconut Grove
Island Delight
Thistle Whistle

Discount Singles:
Autumn Crisp
Misty Blue
Peachie Keen
Strawberry Sunset

Scootin Along with:
Bumbleberry
Flitter-Flutter
Scootaloo

Seaside Celebration with:
Bumblesweet
Sew-and-so (monkey)
Wysteria

Super Long Hair:
Dream Blue
Rainbowberry

Wing Wishes with bonus pony:
Blossomforth with Spring Fever
Fluttershy with Doseydotes
Minty with Tea Leaf
Toola-Roola with Meadowbrook

Babies:
Charm Bracelet
Lavender Locket

Valentines set:
Always and Forever
Yours Truly

Easter set:
Lolligiggle
Skedoodle
Yesterdaisy

Winter set:
Sno-Glo
Toboggan

Playsets/special sets:
4 pack (Cotton Candy, Finger Paints, Rainbow Swirl and Candy Apple)
Beach Belle and Caribbean Delight
Butterfly Island Adventure with bonus ponies
Fancy Flora and Sunshine Blossom
Hidden Treasure with DVD
Seaside Surprise with Sweet Summertime
Spring Basket
Wonder Waves Surf Shop with Guava Lava (Sam’s Club)

2006 Crystal Princess:

Easter set:
Gigglebean
Rainbow Sunrise
Sunshine Parade

Halloween set:
Abra-ca-dabra
Pumpkin Tart

Winter set:
Chilly Breezes
Velvet Bow
Winter Wish

Pegasus:
Morning Monarch
Royal Rose
Silver Glow
Twilight Pink
Twinkle Bloom
Twirlerina
Windy Wisp

Unicorn:
Brights Brightly
Garden Wishes
Rarity the Unicorn with DVD set
Whistle Wishes

Babies:
Boogie Woogie
Hokey Pokey

Earth:
Daybreak
Fairy Dust
Fancy Free
Midnight Dream
Morning Glory
Secret Wish
Sunrise
Wind Drifter

Valentines set:
Wish-I-May
Wish-I-Might

Winter set:
Velvet Bow

Playsets/Special sets:
Berry Picking with Gardenia Glow
Grand Puzzleventure with Puzzlemint
Spring Basket

2007 25th Anniversary:

Earth:
Cheerilee
Paradise Island
Soda Float

Pegasus:
Star Catcher
Starsong

Unicorn:
Rarity the Unicorn

Valentine set:
All My Heart
Candy Heart

Easter set:
Bashful Bonnet
Flower Wishes
Morning Dawn Delight

Halloween set:
Fun Fairy
Lovely Ladybug

Winter set:
Jolly Lolly
Mittens
Snow’El

2008 Core Friends:

Valentine:
Pinkie Pie
Sweetie Belle x2

Easter:
Toola-Roola



----------
~Nicole

[MidnightVelvet]

I'm no help but drooling over the thought of MiB Blue Mist (she is my only childhood pony)

[babyprincessnicole]

Thanks for your reply, MidnightVelvet.  Blue Mist is a very pretty pony, I think!

Would anyone have an opinion on pricing, even a ballpark for the more common g3s vs. the less common?

Thanks for any help!
~Nicole

[MikeysGrrrl]

I have no clue about PC but I would be interested in some of these, I'm sure our resident G3 Pricing Guru's will be along shortly

[Vertefae]

I paid $12/each for pumpkin tart and abra cad bra mib. And I think $8/each for fun fairy and lovely ladybug.

[Lorelei Redfern]

ithink frilly frocks goes for 100-150 unless her price has gone down.

[hathorcat]

I ll be honest and say if you split up price checks into more manageable chunks you will get more response. Thats a heck of a list to comment on.

Mail Order Giant Plush Frilly Frocks – opened and repackaged, never displayed - $160

G1 rerelease: Original 6 (Both boxes First 100 release) and all 6 Rainbow Ponies - $20 for the Original 6 and $26-28 for the Rainbow. The first 100 does not tend to do much at all to the value.

2003 Year of the Celebration:

Dazzle Surprise (mail order) - $8-10
Pinkie Pie II - $5
Rainbow Dash II - $5
Sunny Daze II - $5-6
Sweet Summertime (Euro exclusive) - $8
Winter Snow (Euro exclusive) - $26-28
 
2004 Friendship Ball:

Regular Release:
Alphabittle - $6
Bee Bop - $6-7
Blue Mist - $6-7
Bumblesweet - $5
Bunches o Fun x2 - $6-7
Cherry Blossom (value city price sticker) - $6
Cinnamon Breeze - $6-7
Crystal Lace - $7-8
Cupcake - $6
Denim Blue x2 - $6-7
Desert Blossom - $5
Desert Rose - $8
Forsythia - $5
Gardenia Glow - $5-6
Gem Blossom - $8
Golden Delicious - $6
Juniper Jade x2 - $6
Magic Marigold - $5-6
Merriweather - $5-6
Peachy Pie - $5-6
Pepperberry (KB toys exclusive) - $8
Peri Winkle - $6-7
Piccolo - $6
Rainbow Swirl - $6-7
Sapphire Shores - $8
Savannah Sage - $7-8
Shenanigans (value city price sticker) - $6-7
Star Shimmer  (TRU exclusive) x2 - $8
Starbeam - $6
Sunset Sweety - $6
Sweet Song - $6-7
Triple Treat - $6
Twilight Twinkle - $6
Valenshy - $6-7
Winterberry - $8

Dress Up:
Crystal Lake - $8
Royal Ribbon - $8
Tea Leaf - $10
Wind Wisher - $10

Super Long Hair:
Dibble Dabble - $8
Silly Sunshine - $8
Silver Lining - $8-10
Silver Song - $8-10
Sparklesnap - $8-10

Winter set:
Marshmellow Coco - $14
Mistletoe - $10-12
Snow’el - $14

Playsets/special sets:
Avalonia Butterfly Surprise (opened, in packaging) - $10
Lickety-Split and Portobella - $22-24
Sew-and-so & Tink-a-tink-a-too with baby Keen Bean - $10-12
Starcatcher with video - $10
Sweet Reflections Dress Shop with Darling Dahlia and Goodie Goodie (Sam’s Club) - $16
Wishing Well Princess Playset with Crystal Crown - $12

2005 Butterfly Island: $35

Earth:
Beachberry -$8
Bowtie x2 - $8
Coconut Cream - $8
Fizzy Pop - $10-12
Flippity Flop - $8
Heather Winds - $8
Island Rainbow - $8
Kimono II (KB toys exclusive) - she can be a hard one to price as her value can be as low as $15 and then sometimes she will hit $50 - I would be tempted to auction her as right now she is a $20-22 value but she could be higher on auction
Kiwi Tart x2 - $8
Lavender Lake - $8
Pineapple Paradise - $8
Ribbon Wishes - $7-8
Seaspray - $10-12
Shell-Belle - $8
Strawberry Reef - $7-8
Twilight Twinkle - $6-7
Waterfire - $12-14

Pegasus:
Cloud Climber - $10-12
Coconut Grove - $10-12
Island Delight - $10
Thistle Whistle - $14-15

Discount Singles:
Autumn Crisp - $6-7
Misty Blue - $7
Peachie Keen - $7
Strawberry Sunset - $8

Scootin Along with:
Bumbleberry - $8
Flitter-Flutter - $10
Scootaloo - $8

Seaside Celebration with:
Bumblesweet - $7
Sew-and-so (monkey) - $8
Wysteria - $7

Super Long Hair:
Dream Blue - $14
Rainbowberry - $18

Wing Wishes with bonus pony:
Blossomforth with Spring Fever - $8-10
Fluttershy with Doseydotes - $10
Minty with Tea Leaf - $14-15
Toola-Roola with Meadowbrook - $8-10

Babies:
Charm Bracelet - $8
Lavender Locket - $8

Valentines set:
Always and Forever - $8
Yours Truly - $8

Easter set:
Lolligiggle - $8
Skedoodle - $7-8
Yesterdaisy - $7-8

Winter set:
Sno-Glo - $15-16
Toboggan - $15-16

Playsets/special sets:
4 pack (Cotton Candy, Finger Paints, Rainbow Swirl and Candy Apple) - $20-24
Beach Belle and Caribbean Delight - $120 - they are way way down on price than they used to be but I would also auction them as they could do better on auction than a staight out purchase price
Butterfly Island Adventure with bonus ponies - $45
Fancy Flora and Sunshine Blossom - $18-20
Hidden Treasure with DVD - $10
Seaside Surprise with Sweet Summertime - $14
Spring Basket - $14-15
Wonder Waves Surf Shop with Guava Lava (Sam’s Club) - $16

2006 Crystal Princess:

Easter set:
Gigglebean - $12
Rainbow Sunrise - $14
Sunshine Parade - $14

Halloween set:
Abra-ca-dabra - $15
Pumpkin Tart - $15

Winter set:
Chilly Breezes - $14-15
Velvet Bow - $14
Winter Wish - $14-15

Pegasus:
Morning Monarch - $8-10
Royal Rose - $10
Silver Glow - $14
Twilight Pink - $8-10
Twinkle Bloom - $10
Twirlerina - $8
Windy Wisp - $10

Unicorn:
Brights Brightly - $12
Garden Wishes - $10
Rarity the Unicorn with DVD set - $10
Whistle Wishes - $12

Babies:
Boogie Woogie - $8
Hokey Pokey - $7-8

Earth:
Daybreak - $10-12
Fairy Dust - $10-12
Fancy Free - $10-12
Midnight Dream - $12
Morning Glory - $10
Secret Wish - $10-12
Sunrise - $15
Wind Drifter - $12

Valentines set:
Wish-I-May - $10-12
Wish-I-Might - $10

Winter set:
Velvet Bow - $14

Playsets/Special sets:
Berry Picking with Gardenia Glow - $12-14
Grand Puzzleventure with Puzzlemint - $12-14
Spring Basket - $14-15

2007 25th Anniversary:

Earth:
Cheerilee - $7
Paradise Island - $8
Soda Float - $12-14

Pegasus:
Star Catcher - $12-14
Starsong - $10

Unicorn:
Rarity the Unicorn - $7

Valentine set:
All My Heart - $15
Candy Heart - $15

Easter set:
Bashful Bonnet - $7-8
Flower Wishes - $7-8
Morning Dawn Delight - $8

Halloween set:
Fun Fairy - $7
Lovely Ladybug - $8

Winter set:
Jolly Lolly - $12-14
Mittens - $12-14
Snow’El - $20

2008 Core Friends:
Valentine:
Pinkie Pie - $5-6
Sweetie Belle x2 - $5-6

Easter:
Toola-Roola - $6

[babyprincessnicole]

Hathorcat, thank you so much!  Sorry, I didn't think to split the list up - I've been going through totes and boxes to compile the list and my brain was a bit fried by the time I posted.  My apologies for the huge wall of text, I promise to limit my price checks in the future.

~Nicole

[kitkatvintage]

I'd agree with Hathorcat's prices. I sold a massive amount of MIB g3's last year & those were the general prices I got for them. I ended up putting some in lots on eBay & many lots were picked up as holiday gifts for children. If you decide to sell them, I'd recommend grouping the lower value ponies together & putting them on eBay to catch the holiday shoppers.

[hathorcat]

Hathorcat, thank you so much!  Sorry, I didn't think to split the list up - I've been going through totes and boxes to compile the list and my brain was a bit fried by the time I posted.  My apologies for the huge wall of text, I promise to limit my price checks in the future.

~Nicole

Its no problem

Its  just that if you group them smaller you will get more opinions Which will allow you to work out nice and more accurate averages. Over the years I have noticed that the longer the price check the fewer people reply. Sometimes if you do 20 or so at a time, get replied and then change them for a different 20 or so - you get more responses and even more interest when people spot ponies they are interested in