PC on G1's

[PrincessKelliee]

Hii,

I have some doubles, and some are up for trade, but I would like to know some prices to keep the trades and or sales fair. I don't feel like getting them all out of the box, so there might be a little more flaws, but the ones I can remember are next to the ponies

3x Peachy Italy -
Butterscotch Italy - Still needs cleaning, has some stains near her symbols
2x Posey -
2x Tutti Frutti -
Cherries Jubilee -
Bonnie Bonnets - frizzy hair
Princess Ruby -  ears were pierced
Sugar Sweet - frizzy hair
Coco Berry - frizzy hair (white, symbol whitened too)
Starshine - hair cut, and the first 4 plugs are cut real short
2x Applejack Italy -
Sundance -
Dutch Candy - tail cut, not badly
Mainsail - frizzy hair
Pepermint Crunch -  red stain on her blush, wouldn't come off
Gingerbread - symbol rubs, not white anymore
2x Baby Surprise -
3x Baby Ember -
Baby Northstar -
Baby Cotton Candy -
Baby Blossom -
4x Baby Cuddles -
2x Baby Tic Tac Toe - tooth rub
Baby Tiddlywinks -
Baby Fifi - cancer spot
2x Baby Moondancer
Baby Rainfeather
SHS Flower Dream
SHS Starflash
SHS Twinkler - some symbols rubbed, 2 pink marker spots on NDS side

[mul-ta]

I might be able to help with the Italians -

3x Peachy Italy - assuming stamped eyes she is not worth much anything, unless you have a special mold variant and an Italian collector who knows to appreciate it - $3-5
Butterscotch Italy - Still needs cleaning, has some stains near her symbols - $18-20 assuming stamped eyes, her white hair making her one of the more interesting Italian CP ponies
2x Applejack Italy - $7-10 assuming shy pose and straight hair, I'm thinking a curly hair one with original curl would fetch more like $10-12
Dutch Candy - tail cut, not badly - NM around $40, yours maybe $30? Personally I wouldn't buy one with a tail cut but it boils down to how much it annoys the buyer.

2x Posey - will depend on how pink her hair is, I'd happily pay $8-10 for a PINK one but a white Posey will be more like $3-4
Cherries Jubilee - $3-5
SHS Twinkler - some symbols rubbed, 2 pink marker spots on NDS side - $4-5? NM I'd be prepared to pay $10-12 but those flaws are quite undesirable.

[PrincessKelliee]

Thanks! ^^

Butterscotch has white hair, both of my butterscotches have white hair. Don't know if she is supossed to have a different color  the SHS marks sound worse than they are, they are reaaaal tiny. For Dutch Candy, I have new hair to give her a tail, but her tail isn't badly cut and it looks 'normal'  so I figure collectors would prefer original hair. Other than that she looks mint.

[mul-ta]

The normal Italian Butterscotch is indeed supposed to have white hair, while the HK version's hair is golden brown. I think this difference makes the Italian one a little special, after all she's a relatively common/affordable variant that looks clearly different from the HK pony. My advice is definitely not to replace Candy's tail, better leave it to the new owner to decide.

Post Merge: November 02, 2013, 12:24:45 AM

Just double checked the Nirvana forum, PKW seems to have repeatedly put Butterscotch at $20-25.

[Unicorn_pops]

2x Baby Surprise - $5-7
3x Baby Ember - pink and purple around $5-7   blue $6-8
Baby Northstar - $7-8
Baby Cotton Candy - $5-7 (depends if hair is really pink or not)
Baby Blossom - $7-8
4x Baby Cuddles - $3-5
2x Baby Tic Tac Toe - tooth rub $7-9
Baby Tiddlywinks - $4-5
Baby Fifi - cancer spot $3-4
2x Baby Moondancer $5-7
Baby Rainfeather $5-7
SHS Flower Dream $10-12
SHS Starflash $7-9

[hathorcat]

Cute list of doubles I am sure they will be popular.

As mentioned before, condition is going to be a large influence on these prices. So I will price assuming in nice condition and the only problems are the ones mentioned.

2x Posey - $5 each, she can push up though if her hair is really pink
2x Tutti Frutti - $6-7 - I am really interested in one of these depending on condition I ll pm you!
Cherries Jubilee - $6
Bonnie Bonnets - frizzy hair - $8 nornmally, if her hair is really wild unfortunately she will probably dip to $5-6, mainly because her hair is naturally very curly so flat ironing it to restore damages originality
Princess Ruby -  ears were pierced - $2
Sugar Sweet - frizzy hair - $4 - her hair is so crucial unfortunately
Coco Berry - frizzy hair (white, symbol whitened too) - $4-5
Starshine - hair cut, and the first 4 plugs are cut real short - $2
Sundance - $3
Dutch Candy - tail cut, not badly - $30 [$40 if no cut]
Mainsail - frizzy hair - $7 - its really down to the condition of her hair - she can drop lower if the thermal section is horrendous and go higher if its still in lovely condition
Pepermint Crunch -  red stain on her blush, wouldn't come off - $3-4
Gingerbread - symbol rubs, not white anymore - $6 - going to depend on whether not white means off cream or means age marks
2x Baby Surprise - $6
3x Baby Ember - $5 pink and purple - $8 blue
Baby Northstar - $4
Baby Cotton Candy - $4 - although whether her hair is faded is a contributing factor
Baby Blossom - $4
4x Baby Cuddles - $2-3
2x Baby Tic Tac Toe - tooth rub - $8 - if there are no age marks she could even be a little more
Baby Tiddlywinks - $3
Baby Fifi - cancer spot - $2
2x Baby Moondancer - $6-7 - she can get higher the whiter she is
Baby Rainfeather - $4
SHS Flower Dream - $5
SHS Starflash - $8-10
SHS Twinkler - some symbols rubbed, 2 pink marker spots on NDS side - $4

[PrincessKelliee]

Thank you so much!

I actually have more... I bought a huge lot again  I'm waiting on their arrival but for now, I've listed the doubles. Theirs probably more, The lot had 85 Ponies and I only needed 45 of them  I can't say anything about their condition. (I am very excited tho  )

Pinwheel
TAF Fifi
Sunlight
Honeysuckle
Lily
Hong Kong Blossom
Starshine
Lemon Drop
Mommy Sweet Celebrations
Applejack
Cotton Candy
Raincurl
Streaky
New Born Baby Dangles
Lickety Split
Moonstone
Pretty Vision
Trickles
Sundance
Tootsie
Glory
Parasol
Majesty
Newborns (Tappy, Yo Yo en another one, can't see  )
Dutch Butterfly

[hathorcat]

It can be hard to be accurate without condition so again I would say I ll price assuming no issues and you need to down price from there

Pinwheel - $8-10 - can go higher if absolutely no sign of regrind and no glitter rusting
TAF Fifi - $4 - her symbols can be very prone to fading so top end if she has not faded in any way
Sunlight - $5 - subject to glitter loss
Honeysuckle - $4-5 - depending on hair fading
Lily - $4
Blossom - concave foot? $7-8 - she can discolour really quickly and badly, if she is a vibrant colour with no yellowing she could even go higher
Starshine - $6-7 - again depending on how white and glitter loss
Lemon Drop - $2-3
Mommy Sweet Celebrations - $4
Applejack - $8-10
Cotton Candy - $5 - assuming concave version
Raincurl - $8 - all depending on condition of hair
Streaky - $10 - again depending on hair
New Born Baby Dangles - $4-5
Lickety Split - $6-7 - assuming pink hair - if super super pink she can bump up
Moonstone - $7 - depending on glitter loss
Pretty Vision - $8 - assuming she still works
Trickles - $8-10 - depending on glitter loss and if she has any of those evil age marks she is so prone to
Sundance - $3
Tootsie - $4
Glory - $8 - again depending on how white she is and glitter loss
Parasol - $5
Majesty - $7 - down to glitter loss and discolouration - also she is prone to head/body mismatches so the less difference the higher her value
Newborns (Tappy, Yo Yo en another one, can't see  ) - $5 for Tappy, $6 for Yo Yo if pink hair
Dutch Butterfly - $40

[PrincessKelliee]

Thank you! 

I'm going through the doubles right now, see which are upgrades and which can go.

[BabiChuld]

I'd be interested to see what you end up listing/the prices you are asking, I live in Nederland as well so always happy to look for ways to keep high postage costs from abroad down a bit