I scream... you scream .....

[Sky_Rocket_Sammie]

There are two that hold the #1 spot. Ben & Jerry's Phish Food and Baskin Robins Chocolate Peanut butter. Though the later, I can only get at a brick and mortar store. Nearest one to me is a half hour drive away.

So many excellent recommendations in this thread. *sits back and keeps reading*.

[BigHicks1977]

Wow, Blue Belle is that good? I've never had it... but now I must! I love cotton candy ice cream. It is too addictive, so I don't buy it often.

Grab a pint of Happy Trails and message me tomorrow when you try it

[StoryDreamer]

I love mint chocolate chip, fudge brownie, chocolate chip cookie dough, and Phish food. Wait, we're supposed to name one?

[Eviecorn]

I grew up eating Blue Bell (I'm from Texas.)  I love that I can get it anywhere.  I'm simple with BB though - got to have Homemade Vanilla.  Around Thanksgiving they have a Pumpkin Praline flavor that's off the chains.

I'm also a huge fan of Mayfield Blueberry Cream Pie (regional) and the Key Lime Pie flavor at Bruster's.

[rybett]

SDSU has an ice cream/cheese place on campus.  Yumminess made by the students.  I NEED to get some as soon it's cold enough to drive with it for an hour.  Failing that, Cold Stone Creamery.  Chocolate mixed with salted caramel, raspberries and almonds.  Now I have a craving...

[kaoskat]

I tend to prefer Sherbets because they don't make me sick.

[happycootie]

Grab a pint of Happy Trails and message me tomorrow when you try it

I've looked up Blue Bell online; I don't think I've seen it around Toledo before. I'll let you know if I find it!

[kiwimlp]

I've never seen or heard of Blue Bell Ice cream before!  It sounds yummy.  My favourite is Banana chip

[Aflame]

baskin and robins ice cream is awsome !!! especialy mint choc chip whitch i my fave !!!

[WildBlue]

The ice creams flavors I like are coffee and butter pecan. Either in a little sugar cone... mmmmm, yum

[moonsugar]

I'd love a ginger choc mint ice cream cone right now!

[shockponie]

Blue Bell The Great Divide! It's just vanilla & chocolate, but it's wonderful.

[StoryDreamer]

I can't forget Cincinnati's famous Graeters and their black raspberry chocolate chip. Or our ice cream parlor Algamesis Brothers. They make their I've cream the old fashioned way with egg I believe.

Also fond of UDF ice cream, particularly Superman.

[cuddlebuggy]

The Blue Bell factory is just a few hours away from me so we took my parents and kids to tour the factory! "We eat all we can and sell the rest" is their motto and they're not kidding. The break rooms have pints of ice cream for the employees to eat and they can take home three containers per day. At the end of the tour we got free scoops of any flavor they had in the shop. I love their homemade vanilla, vanilla bean, great divide and buttered pecan.

I like Ben and Jerry's too but they've retired my favorite flavors~ Purple Passionfruit Sorbet and To Russia with Buzz.

Oh! We also have two local ice cream places not to be missed here in Austin! Amy's Ice Cream has great flavors and does crush in's to customize. She has great base flavors like mexican vanilla, sweet cream and white chocolate but also some bold choices such as Guinness, gingersnap,  and Maple with Bacon.

Last but not least, Lick. This place is a foodies dream, and was featured on Unique Sweets. This is small batch ice cream made in some of the most interesting flavors ever.
Roasted Carrot with tarragon, beet with mint, honey vanilla, strawberry with goat cheese~ it may sound gross to some but you can sample anything you'd like. He makes his own pecan praline cones too and I'd buy those alone by the pound if I could!

[melodys_angel]

im lactose intolerant, and I react to too much fat solids at once, so for me its a bit different.  That said, I can usually tolerate a bit of gelato, otherwise, something soy or rice based

I love green tea, cookie dough, or chocolate cherry^^