PC on G3s, G4s, flawed G1s and fakies?

[Star Spark]

Hope I'm doing this right...

Since I started collecting again in earnest from the local thrift stores I've also begun to accrue a lot of ponies I either don't collect or can't restore at the moment, so I wanted to start putting them out there for people that do, but while I can identify most of them I don't know what's a fair price. I know most or all on this list aren't worth more than a few bucks, but I'd like them to go to good homes (and a few bucks still buys lunch!) Any help would be greatly appreciated! (Please note that this isn't a definitive sales list; just stuff I'm considering.)

G1 (All have flaws of varying severity):

Pony Bride: Pen marks and similar stains (I keep getting her in lots for some reason  )

Summer Wing Little Flitter: Wings broken off, bangs cut, dirty

Gingerbread: Tail cut to half length, bangs cut

Parasol: Bangs cut

I also have the 2007 "Retro" Sunshine, in good condition

G3:

Pinkie Pie (V) "Favorite Friends" (the one with the 3D symbol and ribbons)

Bowtie

Sparkleworks (III)

Petal Blossom

Ponyville:

Sparkleworks (I)

Sparkleworks (II)

?Purple Robe w/Pink bow

?Blue sunhat w/molded pink hair

McDonalds 2008 Sweetie Belle

McDonalds 2005 Serendipity

G4 (Open but complete sets):

Target Exclusive Canterlot Celestia/Luna Set

Daisy Dreams

Fakies:

Remco Unicorn: Pink w/white hair

Cabbage Patch Kids Fakie: Pink w/blue hair, butterfly symbol

Circus Pony Babies- one blue w/tri colored hair, one pink w/pink hair

Totsy Unicorn- Peach w/pink hair

Buddy L Fakie (the fakie of a fakie )- Black w/white hair, glass eyes

Thanks for any insights you can offer!

ETA: I also have MOC G4 Valentine Pinkie, G4 Spring Fluttershy, and G3 Waterfire (not sure I want to sell them just yet, but curious.)

[hathorcat]

Pony Bride: Pen marks and similar stains (I keep getting her in lots for some reason  ) - Lol she turns up in lots all the time, she is like a pony bad penny. She is not pricey even in nice condition, but with pen marks and stains I would say $2
Summer Wing Little Flitter: Wings broken off, bangs cut, dirty - $4
Gingerbread: Tail cut to half length, bangs cut - $4-5, he could be lower if she has lots of age marks
Parasol: Bangs cut - $2 - she could be more depending on how much of her mane is cut
I also have the 2007 "Retro" Sunshine, in good condition - $3

Pinkie Pie (V) "Favorite Friends" (the one with the 3D symbol and ribbons) - $2
Bowtie - $3
Sparkleworks (III) - $2
Petal Blossom - $3-4
Sparkleworks (I) - $1
Sparkleworks (II) - $1
Purple Robe w/Pink bow - $0.50
Blue sunhat w/molded pink hair - $0.25
McDonalds 2008 Sweetie Belle - $1
McDonalds 2005 Serendipity - $2
Waterfire - $3

Target Exclusive Canterlot Celestia/Luna Set - $12
Daisy Dreams - $5 [assuming US release]
MOC G4 Valentine Pinkie - $5
G4 Spring Fluttershy - $5

[Star Spark]

Thank you! This is very helpful.

[FairyDust]

Totsy Unicorn- Peach w/pink hair

$1-$3  Depends on her condition.

I'd love to see a picture of her.

[FainneRoisin]

Totsy Unicorn- Peach w/pink hair

$1-$3  Depends on her condition.

I'd love to see a picture of her.

Seconded!  I also would love to see the Remco unicorn, I think they normally go for $1-3

[Goldilocks]

I agree about the Totsy fakie. I don't think the other fakies are really worth anything though 

[Star Spark]

I'll be happy to post pictures when I'm able to (won't have access to my computer for the next few days or so.) I know people like the Totsys- I'm starting to take a liking, myself- so I was happy to see one among the fakies I ended up with. She looks pretty good except that her hair is braided and has barrettes in it, but I'll see what I can do. The fakies no one want can go back in the donation bin (to be repackaged with MLPs so I can buy them again, no doubt) but I figure I'll put them up anyway just in case someone wants to complete a full rainbow of circus babies. 

[GothMummy]

I think remco unicorns go for £1 to £2? I am looking for one myself.

You cant send a Totsy back to the charity shop!! They are gorgeous. I dont think they were ever made in in the UK because I have never seen one in real life.

Is the CPK pony a hasbro one or a fakie? Because I have seen the real CPK ponies go for up to £15 - not that they come up very often in the UK. I love them but i only have one.

[Star Spark]

Oh, the Totsy definitely won't be going back to the thrift store- I don't think she'll have a problem finding a new home, but I won't be heartbroken if I end up keeping her. 

The CPK pony looks like a fakie of the fakie, unfortunately- I forgot to put that in the original post.

[Star Spark]

Sorry to bump this thread back up, but people requested pictures of the Totsy and the Remco unicorns and I was finally able to oblige:

visitors can't see pics , please register or login


The Totsy's mane is kind of a mess due to part of it previously being in the Most Complicated Braid Ever, and they need to be cleaned, but overall they're pretty nice. Now I'm having second thoughts of selling the Totsy, though (especially after what I went through with that braid.)

And I know no one collects the Buddy L type fakies, but I thought I'd include mine because I really like her more "natural" colors. 

[Goldilocks]

I think your black with white hair fakie is a groom pony from a bridal pony set

[Star Spark]

That looks like him, all right- wish I'd known so I could have looked for the bride while I was there (I'm sure if she was she's long gone by now.) Do they turn up often in the US? I see them listed as a UK set but others in the US have also found them.