So this is my very long and ongoing want list. Right now it's mostly here as a reference and somewhere to direct folks for trades, as I've spent most of my pony money for the time being. I'll update as that changes. I'm not a super picky collector, but beautiful hair is my favorite thing. And blue ponies.
Year 1
Blossom
Minty Snuzzle
Year 2
Bubbles
Bow Tie
Sunlight
Starshine
Windy
Year 3
Posey
Confetti
Baby Blossom
Birthflower ponies
Violet
Rose
Water Lily
Year 4
Flutter Ponies
Honeysuckle
Morning Glory
Peach Blossom
Rosedust
Forget-me-not
Lily
Year 5
Princess Royal Blue
Baby Tic-Tac-Toe
Pillow Talk
Sleepy Head
Sleep Tight
Year 6
Merriweather
Night Glider
Year 7
Star Hopper
MO Star Hopper
Sky Rocket (sparkle)
Star Dancer
MO Sunspot
Whirly
TAF Sundance
Year 8
TAF Baby Milky Way
TAF Baby Sugarberry
Baby Love Melody
Baby Dancing Butterflies
Baby Northstar
Baby Firefly (sparkle)
Baby Gusty (sparkle)
Baby Starflower (sparkle)
Year 9
Brightglow
Starglow
Happyglow
Dazzleglow
Little Tabby
Little Honey Pie
Little Giggles
Little Whiskers
Year 10
Sniffles and Snookums
Rattles and Tattles
Bootsie and Tootsie
Other
G3 Divine Shine Ponies (all)
G3 Birthflower Violet
G3 Fantastical February (Jewel Birthday)
Nirvana
Dutch Diary Pony
Baby Sapphire
Nachtlicht