If you could find one pony in a thrift shop...

[Prince Primbrose]

If there was one pony you could find in a secondhand store- any pony, whatever condition you want, who would you want to find? MOC Mimic? A TLC Rapunzel? Which pony do you dream of finding?

Personally I dream of finding a bunch of MOC Mimics, or the international G4 ponies. Imagine picking up Star Swirl for 25 cents, heheh.

[Sprinkles]

A Comic Con Drama Pony

I missed out on so much sleep and food trying to get her

[Buzzingbumblebee]

The green seaside baby with her float near mint, but loose.

[brightberry]

It would have to be an out of box mint Mimic... or several of them.  That way I won't have to buy my own or be tortured seeing her locked away in a box.

[TwilightOwl]

Frankly, I'd love to find any G1 pony while thrifting. But if I had to choose one, it would be TAF Buttons. 

[Eaglefeather]

I would love to find any Big Brother pony, Skippity Doo (deflocked), Cranberry Muffins, or Blueberry Baskets. 

[mlp4me]

Punzie, and why not scoops and mom and baby mo ponies... Yeeeeaaaaaah!

[Prince Primbrose]

It would have to be an out of box mint Mimic... or several of them.  That way I won't have to buy my own or be tortured seeing her locked away in a box.

That's exactly how I feel about it. I'd love to find a bunch of old, unsold Mimics, but I'd need one mint out of the package to hold and touch.

[TokiBear]

I would love to find any G1's lol... but I keep crossing my fingers that I'll find Punzie in some forgotten corner somewhere...  I did find a baby Dancing Butterflies for $0.25 at a local thrift store... I freaked out a little bit...

[Prince Primbrose]

I'm suddenly feeling really lucky to have found the G1 thrift ponies I did... This winter I found 7 G1s in a toy bucket at a new thrift store (and a ton of Remco-ish fakies that I left.) None of them were especially hard to find, but I felt great saving them.

[StarDragon]

Mail order ponies! In nice condition!

[joey]

The boys with all their stuff! I would faint lol.

[Starly]

Any pony worth a lot of money so I can sell it, or G4s of any size, species, or condition so I can use them for custom baits....so I can sell them when I am done.
See a pattern here?

[lovesbabysquirmy]

Hmmmm... I would love to find the Greek sitting Easter and Birthday Ponies! 

[invaderhorizongreen]

I would want to find any gen 1 I could get my hands on , I have not seen any for YEARS ... however I would be happy to find Rapunzel missing her hair but otherwise ok.