So whose your bad penny?

[Tiggums6]

Baby SleepyPie, the Bride pony, Sundance, Peachy, baity Yum Yums, baity Blueberry Baskets, and G3 long haired Rarity, oodles of her.

[ooizza]

Mine are SS Lofty and SS Magic Star and almost always they are in excellent condition! I guess there have been a few Cotton Candys and Blossoms too over the years

[Stormness_1]

For me, G1 it's peachy and Firefly, G2 it's Light heart (canopy bed version, so no custom potential really) and for G3 it's a toss up betwee Pinkie Pie, Sunny Daze and Star Catcher I! Everyone is saying Sparkleworks, ironically she was the last of the 2003 ponies to join my herd... so elusive to me - but of course I wanted a minty one in her original pose, to match the rest of my 2003 set which I deboxed myself!

[Mermaid]

Haha just a thought can you imagine a bad penny swap gone wrong and ending up with more of your bad penny then you started with? *snorts*

[sadako]

Fakies. Definitely fakies. I go thrifting at value village, where they usually sell a couple of ponies together in small bags...and there is usually a fakie or two in the bag along with the mlp I want.

I tend to find a lot of g3 rainbow dashes, which actually works out in my favour as I collect her

[Sokkis]

Oh my, I remembered that I have another bad penny! G2 Sundance (Magic Motion). Now I have 3 of her. How?

[TheGreatSpid]

Sundance (G1) Oh man, I've gotten so many of her, and tons of Petal blossoms (G2). They just keep finding me!

[Diamond]

Totally fun reading who gets followed home by whom.  I am thinking though if we do find someone to run a swap, Pinkie Pie may need to be outlawed. LOL

[mlp4me]

Cotton candy, cp ponies in general,  p a r a s o l (like a plague).

[partypony566]

g3 Wysteria III ..... I had 5 of her at one point. Also Skywishes was in practically every charity shop I looked in last year

[rybett]

So many of these I don't have!!! 

[Summer-blade]

I'm seeing so many people trying to get rid of G1 Sundance I'd LOVE to take any amount of G1 sundance in any shape off someone's hands. She is my favorite pose for customs 

[SeaStar777]

It's a close tie between G1 Cotton Candy & G1 Sundance. I could not get rid of enough of them before more would come in! 

[TexasGal]

It is so interesting to read who everyone gets.  Maybe we can talk one of the more swap loving mods into organizing a bad penny swap.

I second this.  What if we took something like, Cotton Candy, say, and if she was a very baity Cotton Candy, just paint her a different color and rehair, but make symbols as close to before.  Like...idk...a Sundance in a rainbow of TAF pattern? just tossing some ideas out there

[geco234yo]

Some of these ponies never cross my path!  I think Peachy is everywhere stalking me.  And if I buy anything off Ebay I feel like the seller just says "oh toss in a Peachy for good measure!"  And they are always sticky! Those darn pink ponies!