My boyfriend is probably going to buy the latest makerbot some time in December. If we should indeed get one, I can come back here and tell you more about my experience. :>
I can recommend shapeways, tho. We've ordered from them before, and it always looked fine. It can be a bit of work to make the model fit for their requirements, tho. And: Ask to have it sanded/polished by THEM for just one or two dollars extra. It saves you an INSANE amount of work. xD