What kind of mod podge should I use?

[kadajkitten]

So I'm working on some custom ponies and I bought mod podge because some of the paint on the pony's body was chipping off. I used Mod Podge Gloss waterbase sealer, glue and finish, but it's way glossy and I don't like it, what kind of mod podge should I be using to get to the closest look of a factory made pony?

[Colorscapesart]

I would recommend modge podge matte.  Even better is Testor's Dullcote spray at hobby stores. 

[kadajkitten]

Is the spray hard to work with? Like will it leave drip mark type stuff on the pony? That's why I've been avoiding airbrush type things, I've never worked with it

[Colorscapesart]

If you use light coats dripping isn't a problem.