Opinions... Which NC Starflower would you keep?

[Cide85]

Hi. ^^ I am having a hard time deciding which one of these I would truly keep for myself, and which one to sell. As I don't really need two NC Starflowers. Even if I do like her a lot. ^^

Both of them have their own problems, so it's a very hard decision.
Here are some pictures of them, let's call the left one number 1 and the right one number 2.
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Here you can see that the left one has more problems on this side. The pretty big mark on the middle of her body, plus some scratched on her this side eye as well, here's a closer photo of number 1's mark from this side:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login


visitors can't see pics , please register or login

Interestingly enough number 2 has more hair than number 1.

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

On this photo you can see number 2 has more problems (right one). though number 1 also has brown mark on her lips. But number 2 has some scratches in her eye, plus a little brown spot on her... chest or so, do not know if it would be cancer or just some dirt mark... But the biggest problem which I have with number 2 is her horn.... You can see the problem better below:
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

I do not know how her horn has suffered that kind of damage, but...

But yeah both have some problems and I have no clue which one to keep, so thought it would be nice to ask for some opinions. ^^

[HorsingAround]

Hmmmm, tough decision! They both look pretty nice to me!  I have another possible solution.... What if you sold them BOTH and used the money you were paid for them to buy a more minty Starflower?   

[Cide85]

Well it is a possibility in the future sure, but NC Starflower is not that common to be found (so I still would prefer to sell one of them now, and keep the other until I would get a better one), plus I already paid a lot for the number 1 originally when I wanted NC Starflower in the first place. ^^

I do not want to think I might not get a new NC starflower for a long time, so I would definitely want to keep one of them for now at least. ^^

[Marian]

omgosh they are gorgeous, I would keep both :p

[pinkkittywinks]

This is a hard choice! If it was me i would keep the one with the thicker hair, but that is because i like this hair!

Love pkw xxx

[Dyzarktarzk]

Let luck decide?

It's a though decision!!

If it's me, maybe I'd keep Number 1, even if Number 2's hair is amazing.

[relcelestia]

Well I'm on my itouch ATM so I can only see the left side of the pics but I would go with whichever one has the best hair!
I go gaga for silky smooth minty pony hair!! ^_^

[tikibirds]

you can cover marks with clothing. I would pick whichever has the silkiest hair

[Goldilocks]

I would keep the one without the horn damage... But both really look like they would display very nicely.

[Oneleo1]

Maybe offer both up and keep the one that does not sell first?

[Silversnow]

I'm with Goldilocks, the one with no horn probs. And that's true... keep one cos she's hard to come by as you said yourself. It took me 6 years to get mine... which I just got two months ago and for a bargain...

[lochnessmomster]

Well, I was all set to suggest that you keep Starflower #2 until I saw the horn damage.  Overall she still looks nicer, but that being said, the marks on Starflower #1 might come out eventually with sun fading, whereas if the second pony has a small spot of cancer, it is most likely there to stay unless someone figures out a cure.  Also, while pony #2's hair is thicker, it also appears to be drier and frizzier.  That's my two cents' worth.  In the end, as long as you're happy with your decision, that's what matters.  But thanks for the idea, because actually, I am facing the same dilemma myself.  I have doubles of Hopscotch, Gypsy, Chief, and Rainbow Windy (among others) and as much as I love ponies, I am not into armies unless there is a distinct difference between them (i.e. SS vs. NSS or glitter symbols vs. non-glitter symbols). 

[Cide85]

^^ Thanks for you opinions!

I really don't know if there is any cancer spot's on number 2. But... I was going to keep number 2 as well certainly before I noticed the damage on her horn. I just have a lot of troubles being certain what I want to do with them now... I still kind of would prefer keeping number 2 for myself, but... It's really hard to decide as I like number 2 better, but then the damage to her horn... =/

Sight, need to decide. ^^