Unloved G1s :(

[PhyllieBean]

Poor ol' Banana Surprise.  I luuuuurve her, but I have a feeling she'll take this whole thing!  I'd also say TAF Scoops.  It seems like most of my childhood ponies are the most unloved by everyone else!

[Buddafly]

sprinkles.

I don't love that pony.  she jacked firefly's colors, and whenever I see her in a lot, she's aged horribly!  *blech*

[hathorcat]

Great suggestions! I think I ll wait for a handful more and then come up with the 12 or so for out poll...poor Molasses and Pony Bride I had forgotten about them.

[invaderhorizongreen]

Peppermint Crunch is one of my faves and i love all the ponies that came with the party set. Baby frosting was the one i played with the most , and sadly has bad rips near her tail.

[lolaandbean]

I have 2 Banana Surprises that I picked up from thrift stores. Normally I'd put one in with my trades. I can't bear to part with either one. I guess I'll just have Banana Surprise twins.

[Sugar]

Tootsie, definitely (though I love mine and can still remember buying her) - I most commonly see her referred to as "snot-green."  Poor Tootsie!

Either of the Sippin' Soda Ponies.  That mouth...

I'd say Peachy, too, 'cause she seems kind of overlooked.  (But again, I mine, frizzy-haired though she is.)

Inasmuch as I don't care for the BBEs at all, I really kind of like Baby Frosting and would love her DBBE'ed...

Raspberry Jam, 'cause she so often appears with drastic head-and-body mismatching going on...

And Sky Rocket, though I think she's lovely, doesn't seem to get the same love as the other TEs.

[ButtercreamDream]

Really?  Tootsie?     I love Tootsie!

I would suggest Skyflyer, Sweet suds and baby frosting.  Oh, and maybe those princesses with the fake eyelashes 

[SkyCakes]

Hmm this is my list:

drink N wet ponies
Shady so soft
the fancy mermaids
soft and sleepy newborns
I dont think Romper gets much love from the happy tails
the peek a boo ponies (unless they have their bibs they look odd)
dance n prance ponies

I think when hasbro started with more of the gimmicks they because a little less loved but not by me though im not into seaponies or mermaids.

[Shenanigans]

Inasmuch as I don't care for the BBEs at all, I really kind of like Baby Frosting and would love her DBBE'ed...

Same here! I love Baby Frosting, but I want to DBBE her!

[scarletjul]

Oddly, a lot of the ponies being mentioned are fairly high on my want list (Raspberry Jam, Big Top & Toppy, Snowdrop) but I'll agree to:

The Pretty Ponies set (I never see them mentioned.)
SS Best Wishes

I actually think the BBE ponies get mentioned often, mostly by people who don't like them - and then the people who defend them.  Personally, I like some of the BBE ponies. 

I'll add Sunbeam, who never gets mentioned compared to the other early unicorns.  She's such a pretty color combo, too.

[tiktok]

Funny, I was thinking about this right before I came back to the Forum tab and saw that there was a thread.

I don't think I've seen anybody talk about Sundance as anything more than a mention - she's just the one that came with Megan, nothing more, it seems. I love Sundance and coveted her for years before I got my first one just recently, and now I want an army.

Magic Hat is my #2 girl after Sundance, and I don't think I've seen anybody mention her at all. I haven't been here very long, but darn it, Magic Hat is a very pretty girl! Heck, here's a pic of mine: Clicky. That is how pretty I think she is!

Baby Frosting is what made me think of this in the first place - cute color, cute design, dumb beddy-bye eyes ruining everything she had going for her. She could have been SO CUTE, oh my gosh, but BBE. *sigh* If only, if only.

Snuzzle seems to get overlooked a lot - Cotton Candy and Minty gobble up the most of the attention out of the Original Mane Six, and her evil twin/spiritual successor Peachy seems to get more mentions.

[Mirage]

Am I the only one that just doesn't like Shaggy?
I'm kinda sick of seeing her flooding ebay. 

I don't seem to like Quackers either, not sure what her popularity is.

[Visage]

I love TAF Fifi, TAF Scoops and SS Best Wishes!

Tutti Frutti seems to be forgotten...

[hathorcat]

Ok so the list ended up longer than I thought...so what we should do now is make one of these under appreciated ponies a "favourite" Show them all a little love!

[Enolaalone]

Is streaky that unpopular? I see little bidding wars on her on ebay fairly often. Also she is my favourite I need her to complete my rainbow pony set.

Also now I feel sad about Tootsie and I think I should keep my green one, even though originally I didn't want her. Sorry Tootsie.