Unloved G1s :(

[Sandra]

Awww, some of these are my favorites of the set!  Peppermint Crunch is my favorite Sundae Best...

Ones that come to mind for me would be:

Tootsie
Baby Frosting (my mom loves this one though!)
Molasses
Daisy Sweet
The MGR ponies that aren't Flower Bouquet or Diamond Dreams
Pretty Pony Sweetheart Sisters
Pony Bride

I will never understand why Molasses doesn't get much love. She's like my 2nd favorite in my entire collection. Those curls are just to die for. *pets Molasses*

[Daiyuflower]

I second baby Sleepy Pie.  I had her as a child, and preferred the purse she came with to the pony herself. 

[Salli]

I LOVE Banana Surprise! Did you see her rehair? I want one!

http://ty-chou.deviantart.com/gallery/36200609#/d55k8o7

I think she suffers from Poor-Color-Concept-Syndrome. This rehair is so pretty. I think Baby Frosting is only creepy because of those BBEs, I love the coloring on that one!

[HavACrumpet452]

Good idea. I like to pick out less commonly seen ponies when I take pictures so people can be like "who is that pony I suddenly need".

Baby Fleecy
Flowerbelle
Dabble
Scribbles
Sand Digger
Princess Sunbeam
Princess Pristina
Magic Hat
Angel
Baby Pockets

[ember86]

Blue Bell
Snuzzle
Sea Shell
Pink Princess pony
Purple Princess pony

[Leopard_Print_Unicorn]

I LOVE Raspberry Jam, but I love any pony with green hair. I think any of the Magic Mirror ponies. I have Cuddles, but I really just can't get into them.

[Shenanigans]

I'd have to say...

Tootsie
Speedy
Scoops
Merriweather
Bonnie Bonnets
Banana Surprise
BNG Bouquet
Floater (I love Floater!)
Molasses
Shoreline
Tutti Frutti
All the US Birthflowers

[minty-fan]

Crunch Berry(Cherry Berry)
Stripes(Rainbow Storyteller)

[kaninchen]

mirror mirror! i love her too.

and,
magic hat
boysenberry pie
yum yum (flutter)
strawberry surprise
ss taffy

[Sandi]

Any of the First Tooth Babies. They never get any love that I've seen.

The first tooths are awesome, imo! Cute poses and adorable with that little tooth poking out of their mouth.

[achab1984]

The BBE babies. Maybe cause most of them have rust going on in there eyes and its moves on there face.
The Bride pony was never one that I had to have as a kid.
And Molasses, Alot of us seem to be saying that one.

[HollowZero]

Baby Frosting and all the BBE babies.
Party Time
Baby Cuddles
Speedy

[Sternenstaub]

Oh.. Strawberry Surprise is one of my faves.. 


But here's my list of unloved ponies:

- Streaky
- Ringlets
- BBE Baby Frosty
- Skydancer
- TE Sky Rocket

[Lilja]

I feel that Banana Surprise gets mentioned a lot in discussions, although it's almost always in context of how unloved she is, how she is the most bland of her set, or how she's always the one who turns up at flea markets. Kind of the same with Pony bride... not really popular, but brought up a lot due to extreme unpopularity. And BBEs... I feel that people just won't ever SHUT UP about them, maybe the most intensely hated and loved ponies of all!

Anyway, here's my list.

Best Wishes (SoSoft)
Backstroke (Baby Sea Pony)
Baby Sweet Stuff (Peek-A-Boo)
Big Top & Toppy (newborn twins)
Crunch Berry (Sundae Best)
Tall Tales (Happy Tails)
Sweet Suds (Perfume Puff)
Chocolate Delight (Sippin Soda)
Rosy Love (Pretty Pony, that whole set is extremely ignored actually)
Wavebreaker (UK Sea Pony)
Snowflake (UK Earth Pony) (I too think she's the most interesting of her set mates)
Snowdrop (UK flower Pony)

[Mirage]

Baby Noddins was one of my very favorites growing up, and don't seem to see mentioned much. 
Also,  magic message ponies, ss best wishes.. and probably a few others I will randomly remember at an inconvenient time later on lol.