Pony Flavors

[Crowning_Glory13]

Now I have posted about games and ideas for my Pony Birthday...but no I have a new dilemma. I found a recipe to make cookie sandwiches. Mostly take white cake muffin tops and use frosting in the middle....very easy:) Well they also had party idea to make them colorful...well I want different flavors:)

I am sticking with the G4 ponies...mostly due to the fact that they could be displayed and if they got damaged in anyway I would not be devastated.

So I have the colors down...but flavors???? Let me know what would be a good idea:)
Pinkie Pie - Pink(Duh:) - Flavor......
Apple Jack - Orange - Not sure I want an apple flavor but do you think that could be good in cake?
Flutter Shy - Yellow - Flavor.....
Rainbow Dash - Blue -Flavor....
Twilight-Purple...Flavor....I might want to stay away from grape:P back story on that:)
Rarity - White ...Flavor normal might be a good idea.
Spike - Green ... Flavor...

Not sure if the frosting will have flavor or not but it will have the random colors as well. Should I mix flavors or colors and what combos would you think about?

Thanks for the help:)

[InkyMilk]

For AppleJack why not try cinnamon? Or apple pie (why I always found to be very cinnamon-like)? It still has that orange-ish color and very sweet

Pink I think would suit the natural flavor of frosting, some people might want something traditional and what better color to suit old trusty?

Green, maybe something a little minty?

Yellow, are you a fan of lemon tart? If not you could go for banana but I think lemon is ten times better

White...did you want pure white, or maybe mix it up with some chocolate for an oreo cookie flavor?

Hmm...blue and purple are tricky, have to think a bit more on those!

[BrightSide]

Pinkie Pie.. marshmallow flavour! Like marshmallow fluff! With rainbow sprinkles.

AJ, I'd just go for apple.

Fluttershy.. hmm, something light I think. Maybe vanilla.

RD.. ooh that's tough. I'd imagine it'd be something with quite a prominant flavour. Lemon?

Twilight, chocolate, bc over here Cadbury chocolate wrappers are purple.

Rarity, plain and minimalist sounds fine, maybe add a little fruity jam or jelly.

Spike.. I'm so tempted to say peanut butter. So I will.

[Crowning_Glory13]

The oreo cookie idea sounds great...yum. Apply pie or just Cinnamon does sounds good too:) yummm Cadbury is sooooo good. Its purple here too:) Chocolate would be a good one to incorporate.....hmmm

I think Spink as chocolate cake with mint frosting? What do you think? Thanks for help so far keep the good ideas coming:)

[Lorelei Redfern]

So I have the colors down...but flavors???? Let me know what would be a good idea:)
Pinkie Pie - Pink(Duh:) - Flavor...... pink lemonade? or  strawberry
Apple Jack - Orange with maybe  a light apple flavering in the frosting or a couple  candid apple peels  - Not sure I want an apple flavor but do you think that could be good in cake?
Flutter Shy - Yellow - Flavor..... lemon or banana
Rainbow Dash - Blue -Flavor.... bluebarry or blue rasperry
Twilight-Purple...Flavor....I might want to stay away from grape:P back story on that:)
Rarity - White ...Flavor normal might be a good idea. coccout
Spike - Green ... Flavor...lime?

[InkyMilk]

I think chocolate with mint frosting would work out very nicely!

And...apparently there's like, rarely any natural blue foods O.o If you don't like blueberries, perhaps decorating with blue MnMs or blue gummy candies?

And purple is almost just as rare! If you don't want grape, maybe plum, cranberry or dark cherry?

[Crowning_Glory13]

The flavors do not have to match the colors by any means....if peaches sounds great for Twilight then purple with peach flavoring it is:) I am just thinking of if a pony was a flavor what would it taste like....yumm plastic:P hehehehehe

[InkyMilk]

Oh! Haha, I understand now, though I still actually think the other flavors I already mentioned suit them rather well, but instead I would agree that Twilight would be best with chocolate and fudge, maybe even chocolate chunks of some sort. And RD needs something tart and in-your-face like orange or raspberries.

[hathorcat]

This thread is sending me to my kitchen for noms!! I am sticking with fruity suggestions

Pinkie Pie - Pink(Duh:) - Raspberry [simply and popular!]
Apple Jack - Orange - Pineapple
Flutter Shy - Yellow - Banana
Rainbow Dash - Blue - Blueberry [of course]
Twilight-Purple - Black Cherry
Rarity - Coconut [nom nom nom my favourite!]
Spike - Green - Apple

And I would top each with either chocolate coated candy or gummy chews in a cute contrasting colour ....so Coconut has red gummys and Banana has brown m&ms

Sounds like a great idea for your party

[hathorcat]

ooops double post!

[NovelNerd]

If you were making a full layer cake I would have said to make a rainbow layer cake for RD.

Hmm the others
Pinkie- Strawberry
AJ- I agree with the above posts for maybe cinnamon. It would be cool if you could get an apple one bet it would taste neat.
Fluttershy- Lemon maybe
I'm actually not sure for the unicorns.

[kissthethunder]

Pinkie is cotton candy