Selling My Entire My Little Pony Collection. Need Help in Price Check.

[Waves And Water]

It’s been a very long time since I bought ponies online from EBay, surfed yard sales, dug through flea markets, and checked out local thrift stores. So when It comes the original 80s pony current value I’m clueless.

Took a long time to post every pony in my collection online. This includes taking photos of each ponies right side, left side, bottom, top, front and back plus their accessories. And extras I have, along with organization as well. So here is the long list of what I have plus direct link to each category.

Mail Order Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/1-E1E3N6AVA#galleryItemView
UK Exclusive. https://ko-fi.com/album/2-Y8Y0N6AV3
Princess Ponies Year 5. https://ko-fi.com/album/3-K3K5N6AUR
Big Brother Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/4-A0A1N6AUN
Baby Brother Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/5-K3K4N6AUG
Peek-A-Boo Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/6-C0C8N6AUC
Baby Fancy Pants Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/10-R5R2N6ASD
Princess Ponies Year 6. https://ko-fi.com/album/3-B0B5N6ARS
Sippin' Soda Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/2-O4O4N6ARJ
Rockin' Beat Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/1-B0B1N6AR6
Sparkle Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/G-T6T5N55B8
Colorswirl Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/F-K3K4N55B1
Twinkle Eyed Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/E-H2H1N55AP
So Soft Ponies.  https://ko-fi.com/album/D-N4N4N55AJ
Princess Brush & Grow.  https://ko-fi.com/album/C-W7W8N55AF
Candy Cane Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/B-G2G8N55A7
Sunshine Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/A-T6T2N559Q
Flower Fantasy Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/Mail-Order-Ponies-Y8Y0LRU4R
Baby Ballerina Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/Y-B0B4LRU4B
Ballerina Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/W-Y8Y1LRU3Q
Merry Go Round Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/V-J3J7LRU3H
Sweetheart Sister Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/U-V7V0LRU38
Twice As Fancy Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/T-U7U3LRU2Y
Glow n’ Show Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/S-D1D4LRU2P
Pony Friends. https://ko-fi.com/album/R-W7W4LRU2H
Party Gift Pack. https://ko-fi.com/album/Q-L4L3LRU2A
Slumber Party Gift Pack. https://ko-fi.com/album/P-V7V7LRU20
Sundae Best Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/O-V7V1LRU1R
Tropical Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/N-E1E8LRU1N
Baby Sparkle Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/M-I2I7LRU1J
Sweetberry Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/L-B0B1LRU1B
First Tooth Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/I-N4N3LRU0C
Teeny Tiny Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/J-Q5Q5LRU05
Flutter Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/I-M4M3LRTZW
Newborn Twin Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/H-Q5Q5LRTZM
Loving Family Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/G-V7V7LRTZE
Earth Pegasus Unicorn. https://ko-fi.com/album/F-A0A5LRTZ9
Sweet Kisses Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/E-Y8Y6LRTYT
Windy Wing Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/D-G2G3LRTYE
Summer Wing Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/C-U7U7LRTY3
Rainbow Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/B-D1D8LRTXS
Rainbow Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/A-C0C4LRTXH
Baby Pony & Pretty Pal. https://ko-fi.com/album/So-Soft-Ponies-A0A7LRTQF
Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/Twinkle-Eye-Ponies-R5R4LRTPY
Teeny Tiny Baby Ponies. https://ko-fi.com/album/Twice-As-Fancy-Ponies-L3L5LRTOX
Other Releases. https://ko-fi.com/album/G1-MLP-Play-set-Ponies-U7U4LRSN4
Playset Ponies https://ko-fi.com/album/MLP-G1-UK-Exclusive-K3K8LRRYD
Flat Foot Collection. https://ko-fi.com/album/Mail-Order-Ponies-L3L6LRFAH
Extra Accessories. https://ko-fi.com/album/Princess-Ponies-I2I3LOE89

Any help with current value of each pony would be most appreciated.

[BlackCurtains]

I'll try to help.

The first group, the mail orders are worth a fortune by themselves. Your collection is amazing. I would try some G1 Facebook groups, if you are on there. People are going to swarm you with messages though.

You can check eBay for ended listings to get an idea of what is selling.

Mercari is another selling site with lots of ponies, but I don't know if you can search sold items like you can on eBay.

I sold some ponies recently. My Glow'n Shows Brightglow and Happy Glow went for $80 and $60. My Lightning sold for $80. Leafy was $45.

[Waves And Water]

I'll try to help.

The first group, the mail orders are worth a fortune by themselves. Your collection is amazing. I would try some G1 Facebook groups, if you are on there. People are going to swarm you with messages though.

You can check eBay for ended listings to get an idea of what is selling.

Mercari is another selling site with lots of ponies, but I don't know if you can search sold items like you can on eBay.

I sold some ponies recently. My Glow'n Shows Brightglow and Happy Glow went for $80 and $60. My Lightning sold for $80. Leafy was $45.

Thank you kindly. Your advice and sold prices helps me out big time to give me a general price rage for these.

I did toggle from eBay to try and get an ideal price for each pony, yet it got so overwhelming, so I just tossed out a price for each pony. Then added Canadian dollars or best offer.  Providing a modest amount of wiggle room ( open to offers )

I did manage to get my PayPal set up even purchased a thermal shipping label printer to help speed up the shipping process. Plus bought 500 shipping labels. Have a massive amount of Lego sets I plan to sell off in the future. But the nightmare first, all their pieces are all mixed in seven bins, and I got to track all their pieces to complete each set to sell off. Plus there is making sure my children are okay with letting them go first. There might be some they prefer to keep.

Pardon my wander off moment, back on topic.

At the start got way over my head. Even accepted offers without organizing my pony collection and posting everything with more photos so everyone can see the overall condition of each pony they are intreated in. That plus my husband advised me to keep my favourites and sell off the rest. I gave it some careful thought and decided to keep the following…

Rapunzel
Baby SugarCake
Baby GameTime
6 Twice as Fancy Babies
9 Big Brothers
6 Baby Brothers
6 peek a Boo Baby Ponies
Princess Ponies Year 5
And a MOC Sparkle Baby Gusty

There are some I’m considering opening up for Auction or open to offers, still toggling between these two options.

To be honest I never thought about Facebook. I don’t even have an account with them anymore. Got rid of it years ago considering I hardly ever used it. So I will have to set up a new account with them again. Could you please kindly suggest me some G1 groups to join. This way I can let them be aware of the ponies I have for sale too.

[BlackCurtains]

It can be overwhelming. I was when I started selling mine and my collection isn't as huge as yours.

Here are the G1 groups I'm in on FB -

https://www.facebook.com/groups/279407576032949

https://www.facebook.com/groups/570257203105117

[Snapdragon]

I highly recommend Bluerose's price archives! She makes lists of all of the sold prices on eBay for each pony! https://www.angelfire.com/oh5/bluerose9978/PRICE/

[Flitter]

decided to keep the following…

Rapunzel
Baby SugarCake
Baby GameTime
6 Twice as Fancy Babies
9 Big Brothers
6 Baby Brothers
6 peek a Boo Baby Ponies
Princess Ponies Year 5
And a MOC Sparkle Baby Gusty

This is going to be such a cute, and probably much more manageable, collection!

[nessa16]

I cannot remember who made this, but this is a site to search eBay and Mercari:

http://www.makingponiespretty.com/price-check/

Some of the HTF ones of course may not come up.

Your princess year 5 link doesn’t work, by the way.