Your One and Only Wish!

[Shaiyeh]

Ice Crystal.

[shabbychicdee]

wow really hard between Spainish piggy, nirvana sitting ponies and prefect ice crystal
hmmmmmm. it would have to be a most perfect minty Brazil sitting Bow-tie with no frizzy hair no discolouration, just perfect from the factory it came from

[tailrustedtealeaf]

South African Powderrr

[Ragamuffin]

A fairy is capapble of anything, right? I'd say... show me a pony that was never even made! A pony nobody knows exists!

[Leikin]

MOC german baby Lemon Drop <3

[Zapper]

Brand new G1 Slumber Party Gift Pack

[caseysealia]

 I'd love mail order Mommy and Baby  (I know that's 2 ponies but they come together) 

[Gator]

Sweet Scoops

[Carrehz]

Felicidades!

Or, if we can say prototypes, and non-ponies count... Kendall (Kingsley's friend).

[Mermaid]

Pinkie pie!
Just kidding!

I’d pick Spanish TAF Milky Way with unfaded symbols!

[Pinkie21]

Any one of the Tales ponies for me!

[RoseNoire]

Any mib or moc pony we don't have the record of. 

[freezestime]

A MOC G2 Wednesday Afternoon Bride.

[mlp4me]

I'm greedy, can't choose one: Greek Lambaditsa - Birthday Pony  & Greek Paschalitsa - Ladybug

[Taffeta]

Any mib or moc pony we don't have the record of. 

This is actually a really good one I like this.

There are quite a few on the European/UK/Nirvana side of the equation.