Accidental army?

[LittleHoneyPie]

The Christmas baby G1 pony! I have 5 or 6 from buying various lots. I was going to sell the extras and now my husband says he loves the Christmas army! Argh! Even though I like her, I would rather trade for different ponies.

[I Hate My Pony]

The Christmas baby G1 pony! I have 5 or 6 from buying various lots. I was going to sell the extras and now my husband says he loves the Christmas army! Argh! Even though I like her, I would rather trade for different ponies.

NOOOOOOOOOOOO THEY MUST STAY.

[mlp4me]

cotton candy, 7 of her.... I even restore the baity ones I've gotten... I think I've got a problem!
sundance 6... she's so much fun to customize.
parasol 5 I think... will someone please take the parasol's!

[DevlishSmooch]

I have MANYMANY small, unintentional armies.  I think my biggest ones are Sundance, Sparkleworks, and *tail-less* G1 Applejacks. 

[babystarz]

I was going through some older boxes of my collection at my parent's house yesterday, and I was dismayed when I kept finding BBE Baby Halfnotes. After about 7 I stopped counting. BBE's give me the creeps

[Taxel]

I swear I must attract G4 Pinkie Pie. And I don't even like her very much. XP

I first got her in the molded hair gift set and in the blind bag four pack, at the same time. I bought the TRU blind bag set, and got another of her. Then I got an FS of her, since it was the only one in stock when mom said I could get one. I got the Pinkie & Sweetie Belle set and a second FS Pinkie during a TRU BOGO sale, which ended up as Christmas gifts to me. The Christmas ornament was Pinkie Pie, and mom bought it for me. Mom also got me two more TRU blind bag sets for Christmas (but I've since returned one when my original plans for it fell through). And then the first time I went to McDonald's to get one of the new ponies, I was given a Pinkie Pie.

[Starly]

G3 Star Swirl, + her McDonalds version... I find her all over...

[aerie_star]

I swear I must attract G4 Pinkie Pie. And I don't even like her very much. XP

I first got her in the molded hair gift set and in the blind bag four pack, at the same time. I bought the TRU blind bag set, and got another of her. Then I got an FS of her, since it was the only one in stock when mom said I could get one. I got the Pinkie & Sweetie Belle set and a second FS Pinkie during a TRU BOGO sale, which ended up as Christmas gifts to me. The Christmas ornament was Pinkie Pie, and mom bought it for me. Mom also got me two more TRU blind bag sets for Christmas (but I've since returned one when my original plans for it fell through). And then the first time I went to McDonald's to get one of the new ponies, I was given a Pinkie Pie.

Same. I have yet to buy a single Pinkie Pie, but I have over 7 of them. I keep getting her as a gift, I won't complain though, cause it is thoughtful that I keep getting ponies.

[TokiBear]

Baby Glory... I can't seem to get away from her!  And BBE Baby Lofty... I hate BBE's but I keep finding Baby Lofty everywhere!

[kittybethy]

A Ringlets army....and  a Lemondrop army ( all from swap boxes )

 I have a Baby Lemondrop army!!

 When I discovered that there were so many variants, I had to have them all!

[StarZetRaven]

Globe Trotter, actually. Well, no, I only have three, but none of them were intentional. First two came in one lot each, as I've only ever bought two lots, and recently I was at a thrift store, found her, and thought; "Don't I already have you?" But I bought her anyway. Can't leave any G2's behind when it's so hard to find them!

[saply]

Haha. somehow I ended up with 8 Rarities! That's not even including the Fashion Styles or Blind Bags.

[kiwimlp]

I seemed to have an awful lot of Moonstones at one stage.  The odd thing is that once I got rid of them I decided to start an army of her.  *face hoof*

[Snapdragon]

Baity Glory, Baity Moondancer, and okay condition Dancing Butterflies. I think it comes from buying bait/meh-quality lots, because you get a lot of the banged-up ponies, and they tend to be a lot of the earliest ponies. For me, anyway, and then I got kind of lucky and got five DBs!

[hathorcat]

Flower Bouquet from the MGR set...I have about 7 of them!!!! I kept buying until I had the perfect one then forgot I had the perfect one so kept on buying...