I'll try to help.
The first group, the mail orders are worth a fortune by themselves. Your collection is amazing. I would try some G1 Facebook groups, if you are on there. People are going to swarm you with messages though.
You can check eBay for ended listings to get an idea of what is selling.
Mercari is another selling site with lots of ponies, but I don't know if you can search sold items like you can on eBay.
I sold some ponies recently. My Glow'n Shows Brightglow and Happy Glow went for $80 and $60. My Lightning sold for $80. Leafy was $45.
Thank you kindly. Your advice and sold prices helps me out big time to give me a general price rage for these.
I did toggle from eBay to try and get an ideal price for each pony, yet it got so overwhelming, so I just tossed out a price for each pony. Then added Canadian dollars or best offer. Providing a modest amount of wiggle room ( open to offers )
I did manage to get my PayPal set up even purchased a thermal shipping label printer to help speed up the shipping process. Plus bought 500 shipping labels. Have a massive amount of Lego sets I plan to sell off in the future. But the nightmare first, all their pieces are all mixed in seven bins, and I got to track all their pieces to complete each set to sell off. Plus there is making sure my children are okay with letting them go first. There might be some they prefer to keep.
Pardon my wander off moment, back on topic.
At the start got way over my head. Even accepted offers without organizing my pony collection and posting everything with more photos so everyone can see the overall condition of each pony they are intreated in. That plus my husband advised me to keep my favourites and sell off the rest. I gave it some careful thought and decided to keep the following…
Rapunzel
Baby SugarCake
Baby GameTime
6 Twice as Fancy Babies
9 Big Brothers
6 Baby Brothers
6 peek a Boo Baby Ponies
Princess Ponies Year 5
And a MOC Sparkle Baby Gusty
There are some I’m considering opening up for Auction or open to offers, still toggling between these two options.
To be honest I never thought about Facebook. I don’t even have an account with them anymore. Got rid of it years ago considering I hardly ever used it. So I will have to set up a new account with them again. Could you please kindly suggest me some G1 groups to join. This way I can let them be aware of the ponies I have for sale too.