What is your favourite Gen of ponies to collect?

[hathorcat]

G1 all the way, baby!

[Lucky_Ladybug]

This is a tough question. I adore collecting G1 and finally bringing Ponies into the herd that I wanted for years. On the other hand, G3 and G4 are great because I can still buy them new for reasonable prices. I love to buy in-box and then be the first to open the boxes. It's very nice to not have to wonder what a Pony has been into before I got hold of it. And I love G2 also and hope to bring some of those Ponies in eventually.

[Elfpony]

Had to pick G1, the gen I grew up with is still my fave, although I collect everything but 3.5.

Elf

[Sprintex]

Picked G1 for the simple reason that's what Clare already had so I'm just adding to it really

As a 'newbie' to pony collecting I find G1 the most appealing, closely followed by G3. We also collect G4 but probably wouldn't have done if it wasn't for the excellent (although hard to come by on UK TV!) FiM cartoons.

G2 to my untrained eye look more like llamas than ponies (sorry G2 fans )

Each to their own in the end though - it's all MLP goodness 


Paul

[wizzer218]

G1 of course!!!

[StarDapple]

G1 for me.  I love all the variety in the toyline.

[Einhornbaby]

I love every generation, because they all are soo unique and I always find something I like <3 But G1 will always be my absolute favourite and before selling any G1 I would happily give all the others away.

[Zapper]

I love G1 because I get massive nostalgic flashbacks when I see them, but I came to love G3 almost equally. G4 used to be in G3's place but I have grown tired of it. I still like to look at what comes out next and I like to discuss the cartoon and the toys, but I no longer feel "fanish" about it.

The G3s are currently taking over as they are easier to hunt down than G1s and cheaper. So I'd say G3 is currently my favorite.

[HoustonCollector72]

Love them all  but  G2  I'm crazy about , G4 is now my second favorite, used to be my main one, until I jumped into G2s , G3 is next and G1 last, their prices and problems of condition like cancer and deep cleaning needs turns me off to them, but I have picked some here and there , the last 2 I added have cancer .
so i'm on the fence  very much  on them. and g2's are taking all the resources so far and having tons of fun finding them.

[Sparkle Pony]

Poor, lonely G3.5.   

[Zapper]

Poor, lonely G3.5.   

The outcasts of MLP fandom. I think Ponyville was super cute! Everything else not so much.

[TinyShinyUnique]

I love the G3,5. They're like a crash between anime and ponies. I especially love NC, merponies and any variant of RD and Starsong

But my heart belongs to G2. Gotta catch them all!

[aniko79]

I only collect G1 Nirvana Ponies and a while back I decided to only collect the very rare ones of them and selling off my semi-rare ones:-)

[goddessofpeep]

G1 had the greatest variety by far.  It's not surprising since it had the longest run of any line.  I collect all generations(yes, I even have a few G3.5s), and G1 is the most interesting to collect.  I like the G1s for their variety, the nostalgia factor, and a host of other reasons.  G2s have some of the most creative accessories of any of the generations, and you get some crazy color combinations that no other generation has seen before.  G3s had some beautiful ponies, great accessories(scooters!), and the holiday ponies totally rocked.  The G3.5 had some interesting accessories, particularly for the newborns.  The G4s started strong with decent variety, and I love the size of the brushables.

[okamigirl64]

G4!