Price Check on A LOT of MOC/MIB

[LadySiha]

I just want to preface this with, this is just a price check.  I am not personally selling these.  If for any reason they do become available for sale, I will be sure to post a notice here! 

It's that time again!  Someone brought a large lot of MLP into the store again and this time it's almost entirely MOC/MIB, which I have no resources for pricing.  Well, except for you wonderful members of the arena! 

Unless noted, all boxes/blisters are in pretty good shape.  Some tears on the art from price tag removal, old price tags, some yellowing of the blisters.  If you need pictures of any of these to make a better determination, I am more than happy to provide them.
**Also, if there's any weirdness in the names, I'm sorry!! I wrote my list in a hurry and sometimes have trouble reading my own handwriting in such circumstances  **

MLP MOC/MIB:
-Sweetheart Sisters
  ~Wild Flower
  ~Fancy Flower
  ~Dainty
     *There are two of these and one is more yellowed than the other*
-Christmas
  ~Merry Treats
-Sundazzle
  ~Sunbeam
-Magic Message
  ~Cloud Dreamer
-Sparkle Pony
  ~Sunspot
-Precious Pocket
  ~Bubblefish
  ~Li'l Pocket
-Fancy Mermaid
  ~Baby Sea Shimmer
  ~Baby Sea Princess
-Teeny Tiny
  ~Little Whiskers
-Watercolor Baby Sea Pony
  ~Wave Dancer
-Newborn
  ~Wiggles
  ~Squirmy
     *Has a crack in the bottom of the plastic blister*
-Baby Sparkle
  ~Starflower
-Sweet Kisses
  ~Lovin' Kisses
-Baby Pony & Pretty Pal
  ~Stripes and Nectar
     *Rip on the lower left corner of the box*
-Candy Cane
  ~Sugar Sweet
-Sweet Talkin'
  ~Pink (no name on card)

MLP Decarded:
-Precious Pocket
  ~Bunny Hop
     *Blister appears to have fallen away from the cardboard in storage.  Everything is still there (backing board, blister, brush, pamphlet) and she looks immaculate.

Others MIB/MOC:
-My Little Bunny
  ~Fancy Floppy
-My Little Puppy
  ~Lady Labrador
-Dream Beauties
  ~Shimmering Beauty
-Petite Ponies
  ~Ponytail Ponies
  ~Twinkle Ponies

I appreciate any and all help given!  Feel free to ask questions if anything is unclear!  Thank you!!

[mlp4me]

AGAIN? LOL. You really do have the best job! Sorry, I am no help with PC's, but I will have to stop by to touch and oggle soon. :o)

[LadySiha]

The boss isn't sure if we're going to buy them yet.  So all the research falls onto me!

[mlp4me]

The boss isn't sure if we're going to buy them yet.  So all the research falls onto me!

You've got a lot on your shoulders there. Plus all the other goodies that have showed up the last year or so...

[ponycake]

AH! Buy it so I can buy the Pink Sweet Talkin Pony. *_*

[LadySiha]

AH! Buy it so I can buy the Pink Sweet Talkin Pony. *_*

I'm honestly hoping that we do, and I'm hoping I can talk him into listing online with these....

[Aadra310]

Well, I'm old school and bought most of my MOC collection years ago but I still shop around for them.  When I'm looking, I pretty much expect a good condition MOC to be at least $30.  $45 seems to be a fairly common price for stuff I see on eBay.  When they get much more than that (depending on the pony, of course), I lose interest.  Having said that, it looks like listed lot has some that would go for more.

Merry Treats, Wild Flower, the baby/pal, Mermaids, and Candy Cane would be the ones I would expect to have the most interest. 

I think $75 plus for Merry Treats
$75 for the baby/pal (if tear isn't too bad)
$60 for the Mermaids

The dream beauty might also get more as well as the Twinkle petites.  Lil Litters are popular at the moment but the recent prices I've seen them at seem WAY high but that's just stingy me talking.

Don't know what kinds of margins your boss needs but if I were buying for resale purposes, I would pay about $25-30 for most of the MOC ponies and maybe a bit more for MIB. 

[LadySiha]

Merry Treats, Wild Flower, the baby/pal, Mermaids, and Candy Cane would be the ones I would expect to have the most interest. 

I think $75 plus for Merry Treats
$75 for the baby/pal (if tear isn't too bad)
$60 for the Mermaids

The dream beauty might also get more as well as the Twinkle petites.  Lil Litters are popular at the moment but the recent prices I've seen them at seem WAY high but that's just stingy me talking.

Don't know what kinds of margins your boss needs but if I were buying for resale purposes, I would pay about $25-30 for most of the MOC ponies and maybe a bit more for MIB.

Thank you!  This is a great starting point! 

Though, I will still happily take any other input

[ponycake]

AH! Buy it so I can buy the Pink Sweet Talkin Pony. *_*

I'm honestly hoping that we do, and I'm hoping I can talk him into listing online with these....

I hope you do too. What state are you in may I ask?

Ok let me PC the ones I know/own. I own a lot of MOCs and am always stalking them on Ebay so I have a pretty good idea.

SHS are $45-$60 I'd say, I bought Dainty for somewhere in that range (and I only buy good+ condition). Her sisters might go for more, I see Dainty more often.

Merry Treat- $60-$90 (I've seen it across that range in Ebay, mine was $60 in perfect shape but I've seen her sell for more several times recently)

Sparkle Pony Sunspot- $40 or so, maybe a little bit more.

Fancy Mermaid- I'd say around $100 and would think it could possibly go up a little bit from there. I know I'd pay that much. They're like $30 just loose aren't they? And I've never seen them on card and the rarer ponies usually hover around $100.

Watecolor Baby Seapony- I just bought two that I got for $50 a piece shipped which is kind of a steal I think. I'd say they're $60-$70 or more a piece.

Sweet Kisses- Lovin Kisses- I recently bought mine for $100 and I think one could rather easily sell theirs for $70, maybe up to $100 again. I'll overspend if I like the pony enough so I jumped on it.

Sugar Sweet- I bought mine for $50-60 I think within the past year or so. I could see it going for $50 at least at auction and up to like $70 tops but probably not that much.

Sweet Talkin Pony - I bought my purple one for $40 a few years ago but I could see it selling for $60 now. I have no idea how sought after they are, I think they're rather disliked except for by me I think they're super cute. The range for this one is hard to say.

Newborn Wiggles and Squirmy I'd say $40-$60 a piece.

Baby Starflower $40-$50. I think there's one listed now or there has been recently.

The Teeny Tiny I'd say $50-60 range.

I saw some Dream Beauties including that one sell MIB recently but can't remember how much they went for, they're probably still in Ebay's sold listings. I feel like saying $60-$80 but my memory fails me. I'd pay that in a second if the box is in great shape.

No idea or the pony friends or whatever because I've never been interested in them and never took a second glance at the auctions of them MOC.

[LadySiha]

We're out of Wisconsin.

[himmie]

We're out of Wisconsin.

And quite close for mlp4me and me.

[mlp4me]

We stop over every once and awhile for ogling time.

[Wysteria]

I used to collect MOC and I agree with all of ponycakes prices;) They can be all over the place but some things tend to fetch crazy high prices on ebay so you never know.

[LadySiha]

Just an update! 

My boss is out of town for the week, so I won't know for certain if we're going to purchase them until after then.  If we do buy them and make a decision about selling online (which I'm going to encourage) I will leave an ad here somewhere for everyone!

[ponycake]

Can't wait!