Found her! She still has tags, a little fraying to her hair, but I found her! This is really impressive, because all the plushes are in a trundle bed under Paradise Estate's table, so to find anything i have to burrow.
http://imgur.com/a/jBmbOI also found evidence that someone opened a mini coloring set and stashed the evidence. I suspect my neice, but i also suspect my son. I need a fingerprinting kit!
I will trade you a fingerprinting kit for this pony!
Seriously, just pm me if you are interested.