Who Was Your First Twinkle Eye?

[SourdoughStomper]

Masquerade.

[buttonso]

My earliest pony memories are of Bright Eyes!

[ladygodiva]

My first pony was "Sweet stuff"
I only had a pony in my childhood. And it was one of the gifts that have made me more illusion

[Ponyfan]

I think mine was Sweet Pop. My only Twinkle Eyes were Sweet Pop and Party Time.


Ponyfan

[Mermaid]

I had masquerade, Galaxy, sweet stuff, speedy, whizzer , fizzy, party time and gingerbread as a kid. I'm not sure which came first though as I think I got them all relatively around the same time. I remember masquerade was one of my favorites and went on adventures with barnacle. Galaxy was always the evil queen of the north.

[Shimmer Mist]

Mine was Masquerade. My grandmother loved to buy little knick-knacks and toys and found her and a thrift store. She invited my mom and I over one afternoon and gave me the pony. I still remember being so excited and awe-struck by how pretty she was since I'd never seen a pony like her before.

[Lady.Arachnia]

Mine was Whizzer! The very last pony I got as a *child* (I still played with my mlp when I was in my early teens)

[banditpony]

I hated TEs as a kid, and I didn't have any back then.

My first one I picked up second hand was Galaxy. But her eyes gleamed across the room, and I thought she was creepy. So I got rid of her. I just can't get over the gem eyes.

[mlp_loving]

Fizzy

[Al-1701]

Fizzy

Same here.

[Baby Crumpet]

Galaxy! I didn't much like her colour, and her hair was very very frizzy, and cut very very short. I gave her to my younger sister, who has a shelf of well-loved G1's. I think Galaxy is much happier with her. I do love Bright Eyes and Masquerade, and would love to pick them up someday!

[Aquatic Neon]

We had Mimic, Whizzer, 2 Tic Tac Toes, and maybe Galaxy and Masquerade I believe. Not sure who came first?

I always wanted a Fizzy as a kid, but never knew they actually made one until I got older. I remember seeing a Bright Eyes at a thrift but didn't get her because I thought she looked creepy, we used to go this thrift and there would be at least 10-50 G1 to pick from, we always bought all the boys unless we already had 2 of the same cause there weren't as many of those.

[Saber-Toothed Crow]

Galaxy was mine. (Probably my least favourite TE too, lol). She came in a lot with some boy ponies. I remember playing with my friends' Sweet Stuff and Masquerade when I was a kid, but I never owned any of my own.

[Strawberry Swirl]

Speedy! Actually, she's my friend's childhood pony. So she's kind of a special case among my ladies.

[Pheasant]

Mimic! Sweet Stuff and Speedy were included in the lot she was in, but she was the first one I took out of the box, lol.