The weirdest thing you have found in a pony?

[Rachel8125]

Half a condom...that's when I started deep cleaning every pony including s diluted bleach bath. Some things you cannot unsee

Noooooooooooooooo!!!!!!! Ewwwwwwwwww!!!! Why?!!!

[Stormness_1]

Lots of bugs, mould and rust. That's about it, thank goodness!

[SwiftStar84]

I think the half condom wins. The weirdest thing I have found in a pony is mud and that's because I put it in there when I was a kid. My poor childhood Twinkler... She's been cleaned up since then.

[Nebula Light]

Just wow, a condom? (???) 

The toxic pony cloud sounds terrifying. I'm afraid to try to take a head off of a G1 now...

[NovelNerd]

Half a condom...that's when I started deep cleaning every pony including s diluted bleach bath. Some things you cannot unsee

...You win.   

Sadly at this game no one wins I'm afraid.

[northstar3184]

Half a condom...that's when I started deep cleaning every pony including s diluted bleach bath. Some things you cannot unsee

...You win.   

Sadly at this game no one wins I'm afraid.

Yeah really. The true winners are those who've never found an unwanted surprise rotting inside a poor innocent pony.

[Trinity]

Wouldn't the pony smell bad if there was something (other than a washer or bit of plastic) inside it?

[SpookyTrees]

I knew I didn't want to open this thread.....

[Barnacle_lady]

Didn't someone find knickers (underwear) or money once? There used to be thread like this a while ago.

[Gusty]

Wow these are some terrible finds. I have only one second hand pony and it was nice and clean (but I still washed it.) I remember myself as kid putting in ponies some little plastic gemstones

[mlp4me]

MO Baby Surprise worships Big Bird. Cracked her open and there was a magazine clipping inside and it's still in there... Just odd.

Edit: Opened up a BBE Baby Shady... She rattled a bit. Hooray for a full extra rusty eye inside her head. Nom nom nom.

[LightingElectricDream]

I Do recall finding mika in a sparkle pony. Must have been played with at the beach.

[Strawberry Swirl]

I can't decide what's worse...
A condom or toxic dust that makes you sick.
I can't get over that! A CONDOM! That's so wrong!!

I haven't found anything weird inside ponies before, but I had a Bowtie with dried gum in her hair
and my childhood Starcatcher had dead insects in hers.

[SpaceButtPonies]

Toxic pony dust?! What?!
I'm glad your okay now, who knew collecting ponies could be hazardous to your health D:

Ew.. A condom?! I hope it wasn't used at all. Why would you stick it in a pony... Oh dear, maybe it was a remembrance of a happy time DX