aah.. Way too hard, but here goes!
1. G1 Ruby Lips (childhood one)
2. G1 Sweet Pocket (childhood one)
3. G1 Sunset (childhood)
4. G1 Nightglider (favourite pony)
5. G1 Baby Buttons (harder to replace favourite)
Some other childhood ponies are mad at me, G2's mostly, and the G3's I got at Christmas one year, but wouldn't they be sad without their playsets? I can't grab those... okay, I'm a terrible pony mummy!