She is lovely I would put her a bit lower to be honest $7-8 for her loose and $12 for her with her accessories.
Ok, I must have overpaid! lol
I have no regrets though, I would happily buy her again a the same price I paid.
I dont think you over paid. The price is my opinion and it could well be too low for some people. What you pay is what you think the pony is worth; I am sure other people would have been happy to pay that if an auction went to that price after all. It takes two.
She is lovely so congrats on her.
It is also worth noting that sometimes she varies dramatically because she can be pricey to ship due to size. So a low priced shipping option may help her value increase.