Lets see... My childhood ones are Ribbon, Bowtie, Moondancer, Licketyslipt and Tiddley-Winks (the faded one). The others, Heartthrob, Lemondrop, the super pink Tiddley-Winks and Gusty have been new additions. ^^ And the one I paid more for was Baby Heartthrob, followed by Baby Gusty.
I think there are some more NC babies from the Starlight Baby Ponies set, but those aren't on my "want them right now list"