So.... who SMELLS the best?

[Marlin]

That's it. I've decided. It's the perfume puffs for me!

I just had two new girls arrive today, and I love them - and I'm starting to feel embarrassed by just how many times I keep holding them to my nose and breathing in that lovely scent! 

So how about you? Which set (or a particular pony) do you think smells the best!? 

[Jinxxy]

Any G1 pony smells amazing to me! Something about that vintage plastic.... <3

As for the smelly ponies... I think Red Roses smells really sweet and nice... but I did like that popcorn smelling G3! Too bad I hated the pony, because the smell was such a cool unique one!

[Lightning Twirl]

All my ponies smell good! :I use a macadamia nut creme and a fruit extract conditioner for their manes. Plus, I have Apple/Mango dryer sheets in my pony box so they all smell like fruity pebbles! :3

[minamarie]

i love any g1 smell but i like peppermint crunch the best!!! at least mine- the mint just fits the vinyl so perfect so clean an fresh pony..

[foalpatrol]

I have been spending a lot of time with Swirly Whirly and she smells divine... mmmm.  Also, G3 Thistle Whistle - you can't beat coconut scent!

[Jinxxy]

Totally forgot about thistle! She did smell GOOD!

[Taxel]

Do nirvanas count? xD My Italian Peachy has such a nice smell. I used to smell her all the time before she got put in my "case" (shelf with plastic wrap taped to the edges to keep the dust away).

[Spectrum]

I agree that Swirly Whirly smells great, and I love the way Tropical Surprise smells as well.

[PandoraFox]

Strawberry Surprise!
She was the only scented pony in my childhood herd, and nothing takes me back to those days more then her scent does.

I have Cherry Treats around as well now, and I'm hoping to get more scented ponies, but I doubt anything will ever beat the scent of Strawberry Surprise for me, due to the memories attached.

[Starfall]

Whilst I love the subtle coco berry smell, I'm going left field with the Poof n Puff Perfume Palace! paid a small fortune recently to get it shipped over from a UK seller. for me, that's my ultimate pony smell.

[NovelNerd]

Cherry Treats was my only smelling pony as a child. I know a lot of people have commented that she smells like play dough. Maybe it is the memories, but she still smells like cherries to me.

[Rachel-Eyes]

I bought a very nice Scrumptious once who came to me smelling lovely. It was kind of like a fresh linen smell, and it was divine!

My only other smelling ponies are Sweet Lily and Strawberry Surprise, but their scents are so faint that I can't really make them out. I mean, I can still smell SOMETHING, just that it's hard to place what they are.

[Sebby6]

I could just sit here and sniff my Greek Windy all day long

[Bellevi]

Chocolate Chipper!

[Rachel-Eyes]

Remember that April Fools joke the Arena had a while back that automatically replaced the word "pony" with "fart?" I really really wish that this thread existed back then.