If you could find one pony in a thrift shop...

[HavACrumpet452]

Punzie MIP or Brazil sitting Bowtie, simply because their sale prices could bring me closer to putting a downpayment on a home or fixing my car.

[xeevee]

punzie would be nice.  Especially if she hadn't had a hair cut.  But I love finding any g1s. 

[cricket]

Ladybird! Although I'd probably die from shock......I guess I'd settle for MOC Mimic. 

[RedSH]

If I ever found any G1 I'd be ridiculously excited, in a year and a half of searching every charity shop within a 20 mile radius I've only ever found two G3's!!

If I had to pick one? Hmm...Ice Crystal!

[Cynosure]

I would die if I found Night Glider at a thrift store.

[Amsel]

Non-so-soft Cupcake. Man, she's so pretty.

Or... A Sugarberry in perfect condition would be really nice.

But if I'm to be realistic? Well, I'd be happy with any G1 pony, really.

[reanna-mator]

It's typical, but I'm gonna say Rapunzel. Or Sweet Scoops. Though I don't complain anytime I find a pony I don't have yet! My favorite thrift shop find so far is a working Sweet Talkin Pony. Didn't even have to give her a fresh battery!

[ooizza]

I have had tons of luck over the years finding ponies at thrift stores but the one I've been hoping for recently is a So Soft Twilight.

Now that I finally have Mimic, I'm waiting to find her at a thrift store because that's just the way my life works

[spookysage]

Any ponies at all really, all we have around here are Beanie Babies. But while I'm wishing on a star, some nice minty So Softs, especially Twilight and Crumpet.

[mul-ta]

One of the rarer Lemon Drop variants, in VGC but loose, like Agua Limón, white Limone, Italy Snuzzledrop or Suspiro the piggy. Actually I know of one person who found a white Limone on a flea market in Finland, so theoretically I perhaps have a chance?

[Sunshine]

Honestly, I've had dreams about finding a Dream Beauty. I don't care which one, or in what condition... but to me, that's an ultimate.

 Of course finding something like a MOC Mimic or Rapunzel or any G1 is amazing to me. But, if I'm just going with what I've LITERALLY dreamed about finding... not just wished to find, it's a Dream Beauty!
It hasn't happened yet but I finally did find some plastic horses, a Breyers and a Barbie horse at Goodwill. Perhaps it's a step in the right direction!

[StarZetRaven]

A loose and mint G2 Water Lily...

[SkyCakes]

actually as nice as it would be to find a Rapunzel over at a thrift store I doubt it. I think it would be nice if I found another Mimic. So I could maybe sell or trade her for other ponies.

[bubbles171]

adult Takara or a south african pony

[applejackbunny]

Ice Crystal!!!  x