Which Version Of Spike Is Your Favorite?

[Galactica]

G4 Spike for sure.  I like his design and his voice-

Never saw G3 spike, but I'm not super impressed with the G3 animation in general.

I love G1 and normally they are the best- but I don't recall G1 Spike being a very well developed or designed character.  Hardly even remember him.

[Tirac]

because lets face it, G1 animators were smoking something

Or else extremely rushed or underpaid. I think that the movie/after the movie the series became very low-budget.

[Galactica]

because lets face it, G1 animators were smoking something

Or else extremely rushed or underpaid. I think that the movie/after the movie the series became very low-budget.

Unfortunately, I agree 

[Moonracer]

G1 animators were smoking something, sometimes he'd be tall and skinny, other scenes he'd be short and chubby. I don't like the whole huge head on tiny body fad though.

I guess they just had a problem compromising with creating their own designs and staying faithful to the original toy. Also, it has to be remembered that "Rescue at Midnight Castle", "Escape from Katrina" and the remaining series plus movie, were being animated by different teams people (or so it looks like) and thus had different character models.

Still, this is kind of cringe worthy... :/

Anyway, my favorite Spikes are G1 and G4. I don't have any opinion on the G3 one, because I hadn't watched any of the episodes/films yet...

[partypony566]

G1 spike!

[appleponygal]

Definitely G4 Spike! He has a lot of charactor.

[Mysticolt]

I found a comparison pic I took a while ago

visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[Galactica]

I agree that G1 Spike looks more like a dragon-  G4 Spike looks a tad like a kitty (which may explain why I like him so much)

[scarletjul]

G1 Spike but he's only very slightly ahead of g4 Spike.

I think the fact that G1 Spije is voiced by the same actor who voiced Buster Bunny endeared me to him *more.* (I was a big Tiny Tunes fan back in the day.)

[hathorcat]

I am more about the toys than the show to be honest but I actually really like G1 Spike and Baby LSs in the original and I prefer his toy so its G1 all the way for me!

[Bag of Magic Food]

What about rappin' DJ Spike? 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

[DancingPhoenix]

What about rappin' DJ Spike? 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

This should not exist. That whole show, but especially this

It's hard to say, I never watched the G3 movies so I don't know G3 Spike that well. I do like G1 Spike in the fact that he is more dragon like and more like a baby. He's always around the baby ponies and his voice is more baby-like. G4 Spike seems more like a pre-teen to me. But they're both so different I can't say I truly prefer one over the other!

[RAMChYLD]

What about rappin' DJ Spike? 
visitors can't see pics , please register or login

That's technically G3...

[achab1984]

I do not have a favorite of them all. I never had the G1 when I was a kid. I just wanted the ponies!!!!  LOL

[Einhornbaby]

I love the G1 Spike and the G4 Spike. Both are super cute I dont like G3 Spike though... hes a bit too... well, lets say not soo friendly.