Ugliest Pony In Your Opinion

[hathorcat]

I don't think I would say ugly...but I ll admit to not being a fan of either the G3.5 newborns or the big G4 Celestia/Cadance

[DazzleKitty]

BBE babies and the princess ponies with they eyelashes are the top of the list.

But I also have a major dislike for G1 Tall Tales. I think she's just fugly. I also think TAF Buttons is pretty ugly.

[Sapphire-Light]

Newborn sosofts, mostly the G4s, Good Morning Sunshine, Spike and Starsong 

Also the styling G3.5 are very odd, but the robotic looking magic motion G4   fright me

[Watercolors]

I just got my first G1's in the mail, and although i love them, I gotta say... Twisty Tales is pretty ugly. I liked her more after i cleaned her up, but her mane colors are pretty gross. Also, I think all G3s and G3.5s are really ugly!

[OLumeVaSti]

beddy bye eyes and dewdrop dazzle

Funny how opinions can differ. I find Dewdrop Dazzle to be one of my favorite G4s. I did forget about thos Beddy Bye Eye Ponies. *shivers* I put them in the creepy category.

[Yesska]

I must say this:
http://www.strawberryreef.com/Index/Name/twilightsparkleIIFIM.html

It aint any pretty about it at all! Twilight Sparkle on steroids. >.<

[Corona]

The Newborn So Softs creep me out. I still remember having to put like 40 Spike and Rainbow Dash NSS's in bags for shipping at work and accidentally setting them off several times. Nightmare fuel.

The 3.5 ponies are also pretty creepy, I'd say moreso than the BBE.

[Betelgeuse]

G3.5s and the eyelash ponies. They scare me.

[StarlightGaze]

From G4... The So Soft Newborns are the least appealing to me, save for Spike.

[Rhubarbpie]

G3.5's really do not appeal to me, strange duck-like faces ick.  Also the BBE's look pretty creepy.  G2's don't have much love from me either, they're not as cute as G1/3/4 which I collect.  So Soft newborns are also creepy, from any generation, they are the 1 set of G4's which don't appeal.

[Moonracer]

Oh boy... this is a really tricky question.

Beddy bye eyes are kind of creepy (especially when the whites of their eyes get covered in rust), but they have a certain charm to them. Actually, the more I look at them, I think they're kind of cute, in that creepy kind of way.

G2s also aren't all too bad - I used to hate them when I was younger because they looked nothing like the original ponies. But after I started collecting ponies, I got a soft spot for them - especially the G2 babies.
 
Coming back to G1, the Rockin' Beat Ponies look kinda bad, but not because of the poses or such, but because of their color schemes. I think that this has to be the biggest eyeball-assaulting color scheme I've ever seen on any of the G1 ponies (save for a few Nirvanas). Sweet Note and Tuneful are quite possibly the biggest offenders of the whole bunch.  There are many others whose color scheme look pretty terrible, but still I think the Rockin' Beat Ponies take the cake.

When it comes to ponies with a failed design, I think Princess Royal Pink would be one of them... those eyelashes... she looks pretty ridiculous with them. Seriously, Hasbro, what were you thinking when designing her? Those eyelashes look like big bushy eyebrows!

Also, G3.5 look pretty ugly. I'm sorry, but their design just doesn't click with me. If you like them however, that's fine. I just don't find them that appealing, to say the least.

[MANIMAL!]

I HATE the G1 princess ponies--their symbols remind me of hideous midwestern hammered-tin jewelry! They're so popular, but I hate them. And the second wave is even worse, where they have that forelock of solid tinsel? What was hasbro thinking? When I think of all the joy so many collectors get from those ponies, I just want to take it away from them! Bwa hahaha!!!!

[mlp4me]

Ummm... gonna take a pass on this one... for fear of being pelted by fakies...  LOL

[Rika_of_Thunder]

I REALLY don't care for Surprise, chartreuse hair in general is just really gross to me (it reminds me of ear wax) but together with white it just looks really bleh D:

Also, BBEs in general :c

[Mlphammy]

Most G3 white ponies (I could make a list: Star Swirl, Strawberry Swirl, Blossomforth, Keen Bean, Port-o-bella, Desert rose, Periwinkle, Winterberry, Denim blue, Bowtie, Silly Sunshine, ect. ) I don't really like.