There are a variety of methods you can use, sometimes heat will help loosen the glue and make hard plastic ponies easier to manipulate (though do be careful, as it can make the plastic weaker as well), or floss soaked in acetone can be used to rub at the seam line. If you're past the initial seam and it's the plug itself that is stuck, getting a bit of acetone in there can help soften the glue. The key is patience, and persistence.