Who was your first ever pony?

[Sarah-Bee]

Cherries Jubilee

[moonflower]

I missed out on the original 6 too, although my cousin had Cotton Candy.

My first was either Applejack, Bow Tie, Cherries Jubilee or Posey - it is possible I received them all at the same time.

[MnDancer]

Wow, I'm kinda surprised to see so many "first" ponies that aren't G1! Does this mean I'm getting old? 

[Shystar06]

Sunrise Song. I've posted my 'first pony' a bunch of times before, so I won't clutter the thread.

[kittybethy]

I got 4 ponies all the same time!

 Applejack, Bowtie, Peachy and Cotton Candy!

 They are my original four!

[Ariana]

Sunrise Song. I've posted my 'first pony' a bunch of times before, so I won't clutter the thread.

~
Sunrise Song was also my first pony! 

[Jinxxy]

I got four all at once!
High Flyer, Glow, SHS Flowerdream and TE Partytime!

[Ivy]

My first pony was BBE Baby Gusty. I picked her out myself for Christmas - my sister got Baby Ribbon.  Yes I love the BBE set.

[JazzMatazz]

The Big My Pretty Pony Peachy

[Dusky]

My first pony was BBE Baby Gusty. I picked her out myself for Christmas - my sister got Baby Ribbon.  Yes I love the BBE set.

Woohoo! It's not just me! I love my little zombie hoard.

Hrm. I don't honestly remember, all of my 'first' ponies were G1s that were second hand. I guess it would be Majesty (whom I always called Sparkler) since she was definitely my favourite of the bunch.

[Queen Eclipsia]

Cotton Candy! I remember my mom picked her up for me because I was home sick...

[Bebopgroove]

I have a handful of G1 ponies that are from childhood, though I wouldn't have a clue who was my first one, or where they even came from (they could be hand-me-downs for all I know, except movie Firefly), although Baby Whirly Twirl, Night Glider and Coco Berry are my oldest ones, and I was born in '86.

My first G3 however was Butterscotch.

[Saber-Toothed Crow]

Mine was either Glory or Cherries Jubilee, I don't remember which came first.

[klein]

My first was either Firefly or Applejack, I can't remember which maybe I got both together? 

[Daisysmom]

Moondancer and Firefly