The Original and the Best?

[LeighAnnApanites]

Butterscotch is my favorite, because she was my first pony and apparently is the most unpopular. I've got a thing for the underdog. Plus, butterscotch is delicious. 

[Babushka]

Snuzzle!

[JigglesTheCat]

I never knew Butterscotch was so umpopular! :o And I didn't expect Snuzzle to be such a Ms. Popular.. I mean, 2nd place!

[kestral_kitsune]

went for butterscotch cause i loved her coloring

[Shystar06]

Minty.

...do I really need to explain? Lol!

[Ringlets]

I voted for Bluebelle because she was my first ever pony  . Mom bought her for me with the UK hair clip set (the one in the pink heart case)  as a surprise when MLP were first released here  . I still have her

[gemini_pony]

Snuzzle just got one and i fell in love with her <3

[StarDragon]

Butterscotch ^^

[kitkatvintage]

This is a tough choice, but I went with Snuzzle. I love that little gray & pink girl.

[Dyzarktarzk]

Difficult...  was torn between Minty and Blossom...

Blossom won in the end.  She's one of my childhood ponies and just love her =3

[saply]

I like Snuzzle. They all look fairly similar but her name is the cutest ^_^

[Marlin]

Very hard to pick... nearly went with Butterscotch, but I think Minty (eek - sorry Hathorcat!!) is my fav 

[Leopard_Print_Unicorn]

I never knew Butterscotch was so umpopular! :o And I didn't expect Snuzzle to be such a Ms. Popular.. I mean, 2nd place!

I know! I expected it to be Minty first because she's so popular around here, and then either Cotton Candy or Blossom in second because it seems like everyone had one or the other or both back in the day!

[Saber-Toothed Crow]

Minty! Because she's green. Aaaand, that's really the only reason why she's my fave. Blossom would be a close second, followed by Bluebelle.

[blu_clouds]

I love stars, so Bluebelle is my favorite.