Girl Ponies who you Think are Boys

[Iceglider]

Nightglider was a boy. My mom bought it to be a boy pony for me. I wanted a boy pony and it was only pony she could find that wasn't either pink or super girly.

I got a SS Twist in a lot with some ponies as a teen collector. It had a bobbed tail and I thought it looked like a boy so he became one in the herd. I also made G3 Whishawhirl and Autumn Skye boys, since they never made boy G3s.

[Flutterswirl]

Thanks to the Kimono's Townhouse webcomic, I can no longer see Brights Brightly as a girl 

My Brightly is a boy for that very same reason.

[Quill]

As a kid I was convinced that Gingerbread and Peppermint Crunch were boys (and was quite shocked to learn otherwise years later).

[hyenacub]

Oh yeah, Scootaloo!  I thought she was a boy, too, pink hair and all

[Wilford B Wolf]

:blush:when i first saw the mlp fim advert for the show i though Rainbow Dash was a boy i still do sometimes except when she is wearing dresses

lol for atleast a few episodes me too lol....same goes for scratch

[InkyMilk]

Pony, I could have sworn she was a boy. Not really sure why, I never confused Rainbow or Scootaloo as boys which seem to be a common mistake, but something about Pony screamed 'male' to me. To be honest, I still kind of prefer her as a boy.

[Koudoawaia]

Rainbow Dash and Vinyl Scratch could easily be boys. That doesn't mean that I think they're boys though. I think I may have thought Vinyl was a guy at first though.

[RAMChYLD]

I used to think Applejack was a boy pony when I was a toddler

After all, only a boy pony could be a couch potato who watches boxing on TV

(and no, I do not know how my childhood imagination warped Applejack into that either, though I think it has something to do with me being scared of the TV series, the fact that the name has "Jack" in it, and a particular Foghorn Leghorn short).

[Varkolak]

firefly
minty
rainbow dash

there are more, i just can't think of them right now

sweet pop i think it is (with the twinkle eyes)
ginger bread

[balletpot]

Moonstone was my first pony and I've always had a hard time seeing her as a girl. Still do.

[ember86]

Baby Noddins was always a boy until I found out she was girl. I was shocked!

[Bongine]

Nightlight will always be a boy in my mind, and I'm always a bit surprised whenever I see someone refer to him as her, even though that is its 'real' gender

[Shimmer]

Alot of my ponies became boys due to shortage when playing "pony house", I always chose the parents after the babys looks (white + dark pink = light pink baby) I didn't know about genetics but mixing colors
But I still didn't consider them as a  boy though. Baby Snookums is a boy to me though, something about the body mould, cutiemark and name reminds me of the baby brother ponies.


Edit: Gusty was a permanent "boy" in my herd

[hathorcat]

I always think its amazing that people seem to come up with the same G1 ponies that they considered to be boys when younger - Applejack and Gusty always seem to get a mention - they must give off masculine waves!

I sometimes wonder if I was a very naive child - every pony in my herd was gender neutral [or at the very least they were all girls] lol! Which were boys and which were girls never really came into my mind and if pushed I probably just called them all "her". And now I am an adult I know which ones are supposed to be girls and which ones are supposed to be boys so I unfortunately cant say I think of any "girl" ponies as boys....maybe with the exception of Cutesaurus [although not a pony] sometimes I just cant help but think of her as him.

[keylimepony]

As for G1.. Whizzer. It's probably her symbol and her voice in the show sometimes seemed a bit boyish. Sorry Whizzer! D:

I thought the same thing but about Gusty.